I'd be interested to know if you do find any institutions which have introduced single referencing systems across the board. I suspect it would be quite rare, given the depth of attachment on the part of different colleges / faculties to specific referencing styles and the tendency to avoid interference in issues of disciplinary knowledge / conventions. It's not a battle that I'd choose to enter into.
Where I work - at Massey University in New Zealand - the College of Business has managed to adopt APA, despite the wide range of disciplines in the College. But other colleges / faculties don't have a general policy across their component schools and overall there is a similar range to that found at Leeds. There is not only variation regarding the standard style, but also variation in how strictly the standard is enforced. Psychology, for instance, is, I think, pretty high in the attachment scale - ie correct referencing / citation matters and it's APA or bust.
I think the main difficulty arises in 'elective' papers which students take outside their major - and with degree subjects that are inherently interdisciplinary. Ideally, there ought to be a bit of leeway - and I think that it often does happen (eg when a business student takes a history paper as an elective, I think, on the whole, they can get away with clunky old APA, rather than the elegant Oxford style favoured by the School of History).
So, I feel that there may be more traction to be gained in terms of implementation - ie transparency, tolerance, consistency (between lecturers / within a school / at a given level of study),
Martin McMorrow
ATLAANZ, New Zealand
-----Original Message-----
From: learning development in higher education network [mailto:[log in to unmask]] On Behalf Of Dan Pullinger
Sent: Friday, 21 October 2011 10:59 p.m.
To: [log in to unmask]
Subject: University-wide referencing systems
*Apologies for cross posting*
Dear All,
My colleague Michelle Schneider and I are interested to hear of any examples of Higher Education institutions adopting a University-wide referencing system for their undergraduates and taught postgraduates.
At the University of Leeds, at least eight different referencing styles are used by different schools across the institution, with many more variants of these styles adopted by individual tutors. There is currently no central responsibility for providing consistent guidance and support for referencing; the level of supporting information provided to students and staff by individual departments varies considerably.
We are considering recommending that Leeds adopts a University-wide referencing system. We'd be grateful to receive any examples of institutions where a similar approach has been adopted, plus any information on the benefits and pitfalls that have subsequently been experienced.
If you're able to help, please email Michelle and myself directly: [log in to unmask] and [log in to unmask]
Many thanks,
Dan
Dan Pullinger
Faculty Team Librarian
(Science and Engineering)
Edward Boyle Library
University of Leeds
LS2 9JT
T (0113) 343 5574
F (0113) 343 5539
W http://library.leeds.ac.uk/people/pullinger-d.htm
Consider the environment. Please don't print this email unless you really need to.
|