Lawrence,
I would suggest that you do not consider withdrawal from the list over
this over this. Withdrawing over what is a minor disagreement of
principle (and this is separate from the issue of the article) separates
you unnecessarily from a forum where you can air such views usefully.
The problem is that most of us don't have access to all parts of this
affair. An elegant solution (subject to copyright clearance) would be to
put up the original article and all subsequent correspondence on some
other site (maybe ALP's?), so that we could all make our judgements
while in possession of all the facts (or fictions, as may be ...).
Tony
%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
|