hmm, i think there has been a bit of confusion about the technics and
techniques in regards to dissemination versus aggregation. Most of
the ideas mentioned were more about aggregation of information than
dissemination. These are two significantly different things.
Dissemination best practices center around systems like http://
arxiv.org, http://repec.org/, http://eprints.rclis.org/, and http://dlist.sir.arizona.edu/
all of which have significant collections some of which address
the issues of their formation and use.
it seems to me that 'aggregation' is why we have colleges,
universities and it is their core functionality (contrarily it isn't
teaching or research) as their library, but not just the library as
repository, but the library as aggregator of technologies and social
systems surrounding knowledge and its concentration. As such, I
don't think much of the hand-waiving about 'whatever shall we do' is
necessary or really fruitful. Design does not have to redesign the
library, university, or college to function, it just has to learn to
participate in those social systems, which it likely does anyway.
Let's start with the basics:
"How do you currently use publications (paper and digital)?" paper i
throw away via recycling, digital I archive. the only time i read a
paper on paper is if it is mailed to me or i need to edit it.
- how do you search? scholar.google.edu or the publisher's website
- how do you read a paper article? (first: check author-title
combination, second: flick through the pages. Third: Check the
illustrations/diagrams and captions. Fourth: Go to the references:
scan these for familiar names. Fifth: Go back to begin: read abstract.
There is a strong preference for structured abstracts. Sixth: make a
photocopy/print and store it for later. Only if it is really
interesting: postphone all other activities and start reading it.)
the only time i read an abstract is if it is the only thing
available. usually I don't read the article either, I will use
devonthink pro to find the specific areas of the article that should
be pertinent to my work, and if they seem like they are then i'll read
the article.
- how do you store photocopies/prints and pdf-files of articles that
are relevant to your work? How do you categorize them?
http://pictures.tmttlt.com/main.php?g2_itemId=23248 is what i do.
this database has 27490 papers, books, essays, etc. in it, which is
2.2 million unique words and 2.1 billion words total. It is arranged
by smart groups, which are words or phrases that interest me, there
are around 1600 of those, some of which you can see in the
screenshots. all the documents came from journals, the web,
government and ngo reports, etc. etc.
|