Dear Jim,
3.45 Angstrom is a perfectly normal resolution for a structure
mediated by 'wobbly' detergent / lipid contacts.
In this type of crystal the quality of the maps is the best indicator
of intrinsic protein order.
Send some density (in stereoview) to the journal as supplementary data.
Within a crystal, integral membrane domains can be less well resolved
than the intra / extracellular regions
- just as connecting loops can be disordered in high resolution
structures of any protein
- so on occasion a 2.9 A structure may be no better than a 5 A with
respect to the transmembrane helices.
Standard refinement statistics fail to convey this sort of information.
And, as I am sure you are aware, helices can be placed at 6 Angstroms.
Which seems to be your point.
Try another journal - you simply landed inexperienced reviewers.
As in any area of science it takes a while for dogma / prejudices to
dissipate.
Good Luck.
On 11/04/2008, at 8:04 PM, Jim Naismith wrote:
> Dear All,
> I have an interesting problem, we have a 3.45A structure of
> a membrane protein. We have just been told that the structure is
> "too low
> resolution to be considered as the uncertainty is too high". We use
> the
> structure to identify helices which have moved.
>
> Is there a blanket ban on low res structure operating at the moment?
>
> The structure was refined extremely tightly, MolPROB 98th centile.
> (I will
> happily send the data and structure to anyone who wishes to
> validate.) The
> editors simply ignored everything but the res limit (I/sI in the
> last shell
> was 1.8 with a redundancy of 4)
>
> Of course we will begin the usual journal shopping. However, does
> anyone
> know how to convince editors and non-xtallographers that 3.45A is
> valid?
>
> Best
> Jim
>
>
> James H. Naismith FRSE |Research mailto:naismith@st-
> and.ac.uk
> Professor of Chemical Biology |Teaching mailto:[log in to unmask]
> Centre for Biomolecular Sciences |Office: 1334-463792
> The North Haugh |Fax : 1334-467229
> The University |Lab : 1334-467245
> St. Andrews |In UK add 0 to start of number
> Fife Scotland, U.K., KY16 9ST |http://www.st-and.ac.uk/~strucbio
>
> The University of St Andrews is a charity registered in Scotland : No
> SC013532
|