> #6 Identifier should be "period" (lowercase)
'Period' is an encoding scheme, not an element refinement and the strong
majority of encoding schemes have had first-character capitalization so I'm
trying to be consistent.
> #8 Definition: "Temporal characteristics of the intellectual
> content of the
> resource."
>
> What does the definition mean? I don't understand it.
hmmm... good question. Trying to find where it came from.... can't seem to
find the origin at the moment. Coverage group anyone?
> #11 Definition: Spatial characteristics of the intellectual
> content of the
> resource.
>
> I don't understand this definition either. What is a "spatial
> characteristic"?
Paul?
> #17 Identifier: POINT. Why all caps?
my mistake. good eyes.
> #25, #40 I asked this question before, and I ask it again:
> Why do we list
> "URI" and the type of identifier encoding schemes and not specific
> instances. The referenced document is for a generic syntax,
> a URI, but as
> far as I can tell there is not such thing as a URI, but there are such
> things as URLs.
Because this seemed to be the only one the usage group could agree to...
> #47-#59 Identifiers should be lowercase
encoding schemes (in terms of DCMI) and classes (in terms of RDF) have been
represented with first character upper case... I've tried to stay consistent
on this throughout the document.
>
> #60-#72 I do not like the way the ballot is presenting this.
> Why can we not
> separate Creator, Contributor, and Publisher and list the
> qualifiers that
> pertain to each? I will vote NO to all of these agent
> proposals if they are
> presented in this manner.
I'm assuming your refering to
http://rdf.dev.oclc.org/dc/dcqballot/DCQBallot-20000308.html ?
In this case, this document attempts to reflect the agent working group
deliverable as much as possible and as such each of these "qualifiers" are
pertaining to each Creator, Contributor and Publisher.
Do I take if from your comment on 'voting no' that you're more in favor of
how CCP are represented in the alternative previous representation
http://rdf.dev.oclc.org/dc/dcqballot/DCQBallot-20000304.html ?
eric
%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
|