--On 3/3/00 9:36 AM +0000 Andy Powell wrote:
> No! You absolutely can *not* do that! That dumbs down to
>
> DC.Contributor = Value:Illustrator; Scheme:AAT
>
> The value does *not* name or 'identify' an agent. 'Role' does *not*
> refine 'Contributor'.
Come on Andy, now you're swapped back to semantics!
I showed an example of Syntax. The DataModel WG must
address this problem.
> No, I agree we haven't finalised the syntax... but we do seem to have
> agreed that the current voting round should be based on only the two
> qualifier principles. 'Role' fits neither of those principles!
This just highlights that the 2 principles do not meet the needs
of our community. All you need to do is include a principle for
"structured qualifiers", then we can vote *sensibly*.
Cheers...Renato <http://purl.net/net/renato>
Chief Scientist, IPR Systems <http://www.iprsystems.com>
%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
|