So if there is no difference why using srmcp you need the data servers exposed to the internet? Are they SRMs themselves? Pehaps I haven't understood what an SRM is. I thought dcache was one of the SRMs, is it not? cheers alessandra On Tue, 22 Feb 2005, Steve Traylen wrote: > On Tue, Feb 22, 2005 at 02:14:56PM +0000 or thereabouts, Owen Synge wrote: >> On Tue, 2005-02-22 at 14:05 +0000, Alessandra Forti wrote: >>> Hi Steve, >>> >>> as usual we are not talking the same language :) and I need a bit of >>> explanation. >>> >>>> I think everything is correct. Only addition is that the difference between >>>> CMS and the data challenge is that CMS do srmcp's where as the service >>>> challenge does a (get-turl && get-turl) , 3rd party g-u-c, >>>> (close-turl && close-turl). This is why the disk servers them selves >>>> must be exposed to internet in the CMS case since it is them that do the >>>> transfer for you and they do it non-passivly. >>> >>> what package does srmcp belong? >> >> d-cache-client-1.0-34 >> >>> what package do get-turl/3rd party g-u-c/close-turl belong? >> >> Any Srm client. So probably the experimental code for CMS is my guess in >> this case. >> >>> what does g-u-c mean? >> >> I am guessing Steve means Globus URL Copy >> >>> what is the difference between the two? >> >> srmcp is written in Java, the rest are in C/C++. >> >> srmcp supports dcap. >> >> Apart from that, some WSDL passing, and some other trivial stuff not >> much from my knowledge, can you add more Steve? > > Not much, The srmcp supports the SRM cp method where you can ask one > SRM to copy a file to another SRM on your behalf thus making the > transfer asyrchonous. > > lcg-rep does a (get-source-turl,get-dest-turl), 3rd party globus-url-copy, > (close-source-turl,close-dest-turl) and is sychronous. > > Steve > > > >> >> Owen > > -- > Steve Traylen > [log in to unmask] > http://www.gridpp.ac.uk/ > -- ******************************************** * Dr Alessandra Forti * * Technical Coordinator - NorthGrid Tier2 * * http://www.hep.man.ac.uk/u/aforti * ********************************************