hi george,
thanks for your response. i am still at loss as to the political and
ideologiacl implications of the conceptual error you reiterate below:
>Such a conceptual
> procedure constitutes a disguised challenge to the category of capital as
> presented in Capital.
i do not think i misunderstood your point. i simply do not have an
opinion on it, as i do not know enough about marx's conception of the
capital and the state, in comp. with clarke's conception thereof. it is
clear by now that you think they diverge! however, all i was fishing for
was seeing the implications you alluded to spelt out, hoping that this
would maybe help me grasp what is at stake here and why you are all
beating this issue to death. it seems to me that more people have been
aksing the same question i have.
regards, marsha
--
Marsha Niemeijer
Graduate Student
Department of Political Science
York University
Toronto, Canada
'Socialist Register'
http://www.yorku.ca/org/socreg/
%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
|