I'd stick with the term "version". First, it's natural to say
"the Spanish language version". Second, it's generally accepted
that a version "B" may differ from a given work "A" on a number
of different dimensions, such as
- Chronology (eg, 1st, 2nd, and 3rd drafts)
- Emphasis (eg, Advanced users, Beginning users, Librarians)
- Platform (eg, Linux, Solaris, Macintosh, Windows)
- Language (eg, Spanish, Tagalog, Arabic)
Not to say that designating version dimensions isn't messy. Version
C2E1PMLA might have to be the compact way to say "the 2nd draft of
the advanced guide for Macintosh users in Arabic".
Maybe synonyms such as "release" or "step" help, as in "the Arabic
Version of DC-1.1", where DC-1.1 is Release 1.1 of the Dublin Core,
or Dublin Core, Step 1.1.
Date: Wed, 18 Nov 1998 18:29:16 +0700 (ICT)
From: Thomas Baker <[log in to unmask]>
To: Dublin Core in Multiple Languages <[log in to unmask]>
cc: [log in to unmask]
Subject: "Versions" of DC?
As I write the article for D-Lib Magazine, I find myself uncertain as
to what we should call versions of Dublin Core in multiple languages.
We have been calling them "versions," but as someone recently asked,
would DC-Finnish 1.1 then be a version of a version?
One alternative is "expression", as in the progression from work to
expression to manifestation. I like this idea, but somehow it doesn't
seem to work. It makes sense to talk about "the Dublin Core expressed
in Indonesian," but does it also make sense to talk about "creating an
expression of Dublin Core in Indonesian"?
Another alternative is, of course, "translation". But as we have
discussed in meetings, "translation" seems kind of mechanical and one-way,
whereas creativity is required to ensure that the element definitions
"make sense" to a target audience and correctly convey the intended
semantics. On the other hand, we do recognize that "translations"
of complex or literary works can be works of art in their own right.
Please let me know what you think -- preferably soon!
Dr. Thomas Baker [log in to unmask]
[log in to unmask]
AIT - Asian Institute of Technology, Thailand
ERCIM - European Research Consortium for Informatics and Mathematics
DCML - Working Group on Dublin Core in Multiple Languages
Personal : c/o FES, GPO Box 2781, Bangkok 10501, Thailand
Work : c/o AIT-CSIM, P.O.Box 4 Klong Luang, Pathum Thani 12120, Thailand
Home (11-12 hrs ahead of USA) : +66-2-300-3434
Fax ("for Tom Baker") : +66-2-246-7030, voice: +66-2-246-7013
Office at AIT : +66-2-524-5705, message: +66-2-524-5700