Dear All,
This message might interest anyone who is interested in the deterioration of
slip resistance of smooth floor tiles with normal wear and tear.
Carl Strautins (Director, Safe Environments Pty Ltd) has recently written two
interesting articles on wear and the deterioration of slip resistance. Here is the
gist.
When one selects ceramic tiles sustainable slip resistance is important
(Strautins, 2008). For years we have been assured that even smooth ceramic
floor tiles retained an adequate slip resistance for years. Architects and indoor
designers have had to rely on this assumption for a long time.
Most people have assumed that this is achievable. They had to; the Building
Code of Australia states (in clauses D 2.10, D2.13 and D2.14) that the floor
surfaces of pedestrian ramps, stair treads and landings should be slip resistant
and non-skid and where disability access is required under section D3 of the
BCA, all continuous accessible paths of travel must have slip resistant
surfaces (Strautins, 2008).
Richard Bowman has pointed out (2008) accelerated wear test method that
will be considered for future adoption for floor slip resistance testing because
the test results obtained from factory fresh floor surfaces may be illusory.
This is because new evidence shows that smooth ceramic tiles become rapidly
less slip resistant with use. Carl Strautins has now documented some cases
where their slip resistance has been observed to fall from satisfactory to an
unsafe level within just six weeks (Strautins, 2008/2009). [Please see the
attached references.] For this reason chapter 3 of Australian Standards
Handbook HB 197 recommends that tile selection should take into account
both pedestrian traffic levels and wear resistance.
The moral of this story: don't rely completely on tile suppliers for data on the
slip resistance of floor tiles! Mechanical abrasion due to over zealous polishing
can also cause a catastrophic deterioration of slip resistance in a similar
length of time (ibid).
Has anyone got any other good data on this topic they can share?
Regards,
David McFarlane MAppSc (Ergonomics)
Ergonomist, WorkCover NSW
Disclaimer
The views expressed above are those of the author and they do not
necessarily reflect the views or policies of WorkCover NSW. Any
recommendation concerning the use or representation of a particular brand of
product in this document or any mention of them whatsoever (whether this
appears in the text, illustrations, photographs or in any other form) is not to
be taken to imply that WorkCover NSW approves or endorses the product or
the brand.
References
1. Carl Strautins (2008), “Sustainable slip resistance - an opportunity for
innovation”, Infolink Newsletter, 28/02/2008. See
http://www.infolink.com.au/c/Global-Safe-Technologies-Australia/Sustainable-
slip-resistance-an-opportunity-for-innovation-n748692
2. Carl Strautins, (2008), "What your mother didn’t tell you about slip
resistance", Tile Today, Issue 61, September - November 2008, page 32.
2. Richard Bowman, (2008), “Striving To Overcome Recurrent Challenges:
Qualicer 1990 – 2008”, page 12.
See http://www.publicliability.net.au/Documents/Ceramic%20Tile%
20Problems.pdf
3. Carl Strautins, (2008/2009), "What your mother didn’t tell you about slip
resistance, Part 2", Tile Today, Issue 62, December 2008- February 2009,
pages 31, 32 and 88.
|