but it has to be said that a review of some of this work reveals that the
'criticism and reflexivity' generally only goes so far in terms of
exploring critically the wider ideological, political, social and economic
context, and social scientists like Baruch and Gershon are in my view
exceptional.
david seddon
> Dear Antonio,
>
> Your questions surprise me. It seems you are not much acquainted with
> the existing literature on the kibbutz and with what reflexive
> sociology in Israel has been working on in the last 30 years or more.
> So you sound some how naive to me. Baruch Kimmerling and Gershon
> Shaffir amomg many others have been working on these topics for
> decades and believe me self- criticism and reflexivity is not a
> missing aspect in Israeli sociology.
>
> Best regards.
>
> Silvina Gesser
>
|