While this is true, sadly C isn't going to give you any better time
accuracy if it's running on a normal computer. The bigger killer that
many people are going to run into isn't whether or not a given language
has garbage collection hamming up their processing but the fact that
stimulus presentation is being done from a desktop computer. The
variety of background processes doing different things at different
times, like looking for updates or checking the status of your IRQ's are
all going to have to be factored into your timing. A real solution
would be to use a real time hardware / OS solution (linux is not an real
time OS, nor it windows or mac), however the costs related to doing this
are usually prohibitively expensive and the constraints of real time
environments make things like video based stimulus presentation
difficult or impossible. Sadly this doesn't really answer your question
but presents more of a rabbit hole filled with embedded computing
hardware (thou.. some of that hardware is java based).
-Garrrett
Juanjo Lull (UPV) wrote:
> Dear Mathieu,
> Java is not a low-level language such as C. Thus, the time accuracy is
> quite less stringent than the time accuracy present in other
> programming languages. Furthermore, garbage collection (i.e.
> destruction of variables because they are not being currently used)
> can happen at any time by default.
> So the short answer is that Java does not guarantee time accuracy. It
> is an excellent programming language for object oriented programming,
> but it is not the best option: Workarounds can be done, but it is very
> difficult to work with Java when synchronization is of high priority
> anyway.
> I hope this helps.
> Yours sincerely,
> Juan J.
>
> Mathieu d'Acremont wrote:
>> Dear All,
>>
>> I would like to use the Java Programming Language to display stimuli
>> and record response in a fMRI study (and then of course use SPM to
>> analyze the data). I wonder how synchronization with the scanner can
>> be done with Java an if Java guarantee time accuracy. Does anybody
>> have experience with Java in fMRI experiment?
>>
>> Best,
>>
>
|