You are of course entitled to your opinion - albeit
Pete asked for feedback and I gave it - honestly and
sincerely. I am sorry to see you find that
unacceptable. I do not intend to leave the list and I
look forward to seeing a constructive comment from you
Kindly look at the archive for the seminar - I didn't
post for me - I posted for the teachers with whom I
work. Do you see engagement? Do you see the teachers'
websites being discussed in the reviews? Kindly before
attacking me do check if my posting is evidentially
You might well be interested in other email I have
received thanking me for being honest enough to speak
out. Such is academic freedom i.e. to hold an opinion
that is evidentially different from other people.
Warm regards, and thanks for your honesty too,
--- Marie Huxtable <[log in to unmask]> wrote:
> I find this deeply offensive. Whatever your intent,
> have experienced your postings as consistently
> egocentric, aggressive and abusive, totally
> overwhelming the intellectual contribution you
> obviously could make. The impact on me has been to
> exclude me from entering the space for fear of
> suffering the personal attack that I have seen you
> make on others, or doing what I am doing now;
> my own values by responding with anger.
> If you find the seminar of no use then I for one
> be relieved, and very grateful, if you would leave
> conversation to those who do.
> Yours from the margins