Heterodox Economics Newsletter
Issue 254
November 04, 2019
web
pdf
Heterodox Economics Directory
During public talks or in teaching contexts I am sometimes asked, whether there exists a clear-cut heterodox alternative to standard theories of individual economic decision-making. While there are some obvious responses to this question pointing to classic concepts - like social emulation of consumer preferences, consumption-learning, rent-seeking behavior, mark-up pricing or the marginal propensity to consume - many of these concepts operate on a systemic, rather than individual level, and are, hence, sometimes difficult to apply directly to individual decisions without invoking further assumptions. Similar issues can come up, when discussing the role of the ascent of behavioral economics and its impact on the development of economics in general (see also here or here for recent evaluations of this matter).
In such contexts it is, in my view, helpful to point out that a fuller heterodox theory of purposeful behavior does indeed exist. It has its roots in the early works of Herbert Simon, builds on "smart heuristics" and is sometimes dubbed 'ecological rationality' (for an introduction see here). It has been developed mainly in psychology and a key idea underlying this approach is that purposeful human action often employs mental shortcuts to approach complex phenomena, that are successful in application and, hence, evolutionary stable. A simple example is the physician's principle "do no harm" that shortly explicates some kind of MaxiMin decision rule. Another example, is Simon's idea of satisficing, which can be understood as a shortcut to circumvent costly/impossible procedures of optimization.
In my view, three major arguments can be made for embracing such a view. First, the concept of smart heuristics allows for deriving some of the more systemic heterodox arguments on behavioral patterns (e.g. marginal propensities to consume, cooperative attitudes or herd behavior).
Second, smart heuristics often allow for explaining many of the 'biases' found in conventional behavioral economics instead of simply 'recording' them as anomalies - indeed it makes the latter's modifications of standard utility functions sometimes look like epicycles in the Ptolemaic theory of celestial motion. For instance, in this vein the famous 'status quo bias' can be rationalized as a form of intuitive defense against fundamental uncertainty (as future incomes or belongings are discounted relative to those already owned).
Finally, a smart heuristics perspective provides conceptual alternatives, which has a twofold impact. For one, these alternative concepts help to illustrate how the tendency to frame findings in behavioral economics in terms of standard models contributes to an "assimilation" of behavioral ideas. For another, smart heuristics may also emerge from dealing critically with the inherent practical implications of the standard approach - e.g., when assuming fundamental uncertainty (e.g. here) or complex, multi-dimensional choice-options (e.g. here).
Hence, in sum I would argue that the smart heuristics approach can be seen as a highly useful complement to more established heterodox modes of analyzing behavioral patterns.
All the best,
Jakob
©
public domain
Table of contents
- Call for Papers
- 11th Annual Conference in Political Economy (Ferrara, Sept. 2020)
- 15th Forum of the World Association for Political Economy (Athens, August 2020)
- 1st International ASCOPE Symposium (Paris, June 2020)
- 3rd Macroeconomics in Perspective Workshop (Paris, April 2020)
- 4th International Conference on Cultural Political Economy (Staffordshire, Jan 2020)
- 56th ITH Conference "Capital, Migration and the Left" (Linz, Sept 2020)
- 5th Nordic Post-Keynesian Conference (Aalborg, April 2020)
- 5th Nordic Post-Keynesian Conference (Aalborg, April 2020)
- AFFE @ Midwest Economics Association Annual Meeting (US, March 2020)
- Annual ESPAnet Conference (Leuven, Sept. 2020)
- Call for Book Chapter Proposals: "(De)automating the Future"
- Cambridge Journal of Economics: Special Issue on “Financialisation in developing and emerging economies: Manifestations, Drivers and Implications”
- Capitalism & Contention Conference (New York, March 2020)
- Conference on Achieving Sustainable Development in LDCs (Helsinki, Oct. 2020)
- Conference on Strategies for Degrowth in Europe (Vienna, June 2020)
- Cuadernos de Economía Crítica: Special Issue on "The Science of Sustainability under structural crisis and the unsustainability of life"
- History of Economic Society Conference (Utrecht, June 2020)
- Workshop on "Patents as Capital" (Stockholm, Sept 2020)
- YSI at International Conference Minsky at 100 (Milan, Dec. 2019)
- Call for Participants
- 13th AHE postgraduate workshop on advanced research methods (Leeds, Jan. 2020)
- 15th Annual AFIT-AFEE Student Scholars Award Competition
- 2nd Workshop on "Teaching History of Economic Thought and Pluralism in Economics" (London, Nov. 2019)
- Conference "European industrial policy - a tool for a Green New Deal" (Brussels, Dec. 2020)
- GLOBE 2019 Winter School in International Relations (Leysin, Feb. 2020)
- International Master's Course "Economic Policies in the Age of Globalisation" (EPOG 2.0)
- Pluralistic Teaching Workshops at ICAPE Conference 2020 (San Diego, January 2020)
- Job Postings
- California State University San Bernardino, US
- Colorado State University, US
- Progressive Economy Forum, UK
- St. John's University, US
- Trinity College, US
- University of Amsterdam, Netherlands
- University of Manitoba, US
- University of Texas, US
- Awards
- Call for Nominations: Joseph J. Spengler Book Prize
- Calls for Nominations: Awards of ESHET Conference
- Winner Announcement: EAEPE Research Prizes
- Journals
- Economy and Society, 48 (3)
- European Journal of Economics and Economic Policies 16 (2)
- Feminist Economics 25 (4)
- Historical Materialism, 27 (3)
- International Critical Thought 9 (3)
- Journal of the History of Economic Thought, 41 (4)
- Rethinking Marxism 31 (4)
- Review of Keynesian Economics 7 (4)
- Review of Radical Political Economics 51 (4)
- Books and Book Series
- A Modern Guide to State Intervention Economic Policies for Growth and Sustainability
- Class History and Class Practices in the Periphery of Capitalism
- Finance, Growth and Inequality Post-Keynesian Perspectives
- John Maynard Keynes: The Art of Choosing the Right Model
- Macroeconomics
- Nationalism on the Internet: Critical Theory and Ideology in the Age of Social Media and Fake News
- None so Fit to Break the Chains: Marx's Ethics of Self-Emancipation
- Progressive Post-Keynesian Economics Dealing with Reality
- Revolutionizing World Trade: How Disruptive Technologies Open Opportunities for All
- Towards a Political Economy of Degrowth
- Understanding Marxism
- Veblen’s America: The Conspicuous Case of Donald J. Trump
- For Your Information
- World Economics Association Commentaries is looking for a co-editor
To unsubscribe from the CAPITAL-AND-CLASS list, click the following link:
https://www.jiscmail.ac.uk/cgi-bin/webadmin?SUBED1=CAPITAL-AND-CLASS&A=1