Print

Print


PLEASE NOTE: When you click 'Reply' to any message it will be sent to all RAMESES List members. If you only want to reply to the sender please remove [log in to unmask] from the 'To:' section of your email.

Dear Alison,


It might be beneficial in the first instance to take a step back and ask - what is the architecture of referral? Developing a middle-ranged framework for referral might become a valuable output of your research, so that service deliverers across healthcare and other sectors can consider the many factors at play (service level, clinical, social and psychological) in understanding referral success or failure.


you wrote:

Having read literature and examples of realist studies however I am perplexed as to what the initiative it is that I should actually be evaluating. I believe "referral" is a complex intervention in itself so am tempted to evaluate it as such but my confusion lies in it not being an initiative per se. Would I be better concentrating on an intervention already in place to improve referral?

I think it's justifiable to conceive of the referral process as the intervention you are investigating. There are many people with this kind of focus using realist evaluation to study service re-design/improvement. At the core of the intervention is the decision-making process: to refer or not, and/or to refer to an option among a variety of options. It would be useful to sketch out the C, M, O definitions as well: the mechanism response for example could be seen generally as referral decision making . The mechanism resource can include initiatives to improve referrals (e.g., training).
The context of referral may be aspects such as adequate staffing, awareness of available services, quality of doctor-patient communication etc. 
Outcomes would likely include the big picture outcomes of interest, e.g.,  clinical and health outcomes based on referral appropriateness/success etc.


Finally, you might consider a distinction between the referral decision making process and the referral pathway. The former is the mechanisms that is triggered in the minds of healthcare providers responsible for referring and the latter includes the wider context of the healthcare system that will include barriers and enablers in relation to referral decision making. 


best of luck,

Justin

 



Justin Jagosh, Ph.D
Honorary Research Associate
Institute of Psychology, Health and Society
University of Liverpool, United Kingdom


Centre for Advancement in Realist Evaluation and Synthesis (CARES)
www.realistmethodology-cares.org






From: Realist and Meta-narrative Evidence Synthesis: Evolving Standards <[log in to unmask]> on behalf of alison musgrove <[log in to unmask]>
Sent: May 26, 2019 11:06
To: [log in to unmask]
Subject: What should I evaluate ?
 

PLEASE NOTE: When you click 'Reply' to any message it will be sent to all RAMESES List members. If you only want to reply to the sender please remove [log in to unmask] from the 'To:' section of your email.

Dear Group
I wonder if anyone could offer some help?
I am currently designing a study for a PhD proposal which aims to understand referral of a disease for specialist management. I very much believe that a realist evaluation would be appropriate and indeed ideal for this work. 
Having read literature and examples of realist studies however I am perplexed as to what the initiative it is that I should actually be evaluating. I believe "referral" is a complex intervention in itself so am tempted to evaluate it as such but my confusion lies in it not being an initiative per se. Would I be better concentrating on an intervention already in place to improve referral,
e.g. health professional education? 
I do not really wish to do this as a rationale for the research is that these are not effective, or not as effective as they might be, due to a lack of understanding of referral processes which currently occur in various healthcare settings and contexts.
Any advice would be greatly appreciated 
Kind regards
Alison 
To UNSUBSCRIBE please see: https://www.jiscmail.ac.uk/help/subscribers/faq.html#join
To UNSUBSCRIBE please see: https://www.jiscmail.ac.uk/help/subscribers/faq.html#join