Thank you, Ben, for this important discussion and your solid critique to start. Based on only your document--so not cross-checking, with deepest apologies for any errors which I make as a result and please identify any mistakes which I make--there are many other issues, some of which are:
5. Do we trust governments to report reliably, fairly, and accurately? How could we better support GNDR
http://www.gndr.org/ and others in holding governments to account? How could we better engage electorates to think more deeply and broadly about the topics on which they vote? As you note, Ben, decentralising, offloading, and governments generally moving towards privatised, for-profit models are pervading in many (not all) locations at the moment. Does this approach serve DRR and how could we evaluate and critique it?
7. The usual discussions on silent disasters, hidden disaster-affected people, and smaller scales, not just the people, issues, events, and processes which hit the headlines. How to better incorporate these vulnerabilities, resiliences, hazards, risks, disasters, and disastrous conditions into the SFDRR processes?
Shortly after SFDRR was signed, we produced an IJDRS issue
http://www.ijdrs.com/EN/volumn/volumn_1155.shtml with preliminary analyses, especially aiming to push forward some of the topics missing--but ourselves still missing numerous, important discussions. Let's continue the work and ensure that SFDRR not only ticks its own boxes, but also inspires action for topics and people(s) which SFDRR does not address. Thank you for starting this discussion and looking forward to hearing from others,
Ilan
Looking at the final programme of the Cancun Global Platform for Disaster Reduction’s and the list of preparatory and side events, six clusters of issues seem to me areas where critical analysis should be applied and where advocacy might prove fruitful. I attach a two page discussion of these. I send it as an invitation to hear what you think are the crucial issues that should be discussed. What are the silences that still need to be broken?
I look forward to hearing from many of you on these sites or in a personal email.
Thanks!
BEN
Dr. Ben Wisner
Visiting Professor, Institute for Risk and Disaster Reduction, University College London, UK
& Environmental Studies Program, Oberlin College, Oberlin, OH, USA