 |
 |
Now available online. University of Toronto Law Journal - Volume 66, Number 2, Spring 2016 <http://bit.ly/utlj662> http://bit.ly/utlj662 ARTICLES An economic analysis of waiver of tort in negligence actions Edward M Iacobucci and Michael J Trebilcock The legal status, scope, and policy implications of the waiver of tort doctrine have been a prominent, controversial, and unresolved feature of many recent class action proceedings in Canada, especially in products liability cases, where plaintiffs have sought to claim disgorgement of profits or revenues as an alternative to proof of damage or injury. The doctrine in recent years has been invoked frequently by plaintiffs in negligence class actions, though its legal status in such a context remains uncertain, as it has not been judicially decided. The article assesses the waiver of tort doctrine from an economic perspective. It argues that decoupling remedies from actual damages in negligence cases generally, or in products liability cases in particular, is not well founded from an economic perspective. Theory and evidence suggests that the deterrence and insurance aspects of negligence law are best achieved by linking remedies to losses actually suffered. In many contexts, disgorgement of gains from activities entailing negligent conduct may induce socially wasteful forms of over-deterrence. Economic analysis does not support the waiver of tort doctrine. <http://bit.ly/utljaopm16d> http://bit.ly/utljaopm16d The inhospitable court Elaine Craig The media coverage and countless stories that have been told by survivors of sexualized violence in the lead up to, throughout, and following the Jian Ghomeshi trial have shone a spotlight on the brutality of the courtroom process for survivors of sexualized violence. "The Inhospitable Court" is not an examination of the Ghomeshi trial itself. The article focuses more generally on the sexual assault trial process - its design, its traditions, its script - and the trauma it causes to those who find themselves forced to relive their experiences in a very particular way in front of a judge, lawyers, the media, and the general public. Using trial transcripts from recent cases, it describes the profound power differentials that occur and the threat to self the trial process poses for complainants - regardless of the verdict. It also offers some suggestions for how lawyers, judges, and legislators could make that experience less traumatic for those who turn to the criminal justice system to respond to the sexual harms they have endured. <http://bit.ly/utljaopm16> http://bit.ly/utljaopm16 Disgorgement: From property to contract Nicholas W Sage The article develops an understanding of the disgorgement remedy in private law by moving between the proprietary context, where the remedy has long been awarded, and the contractual context, where the remedy is relatively new and still controversial. The resulting account can explain the emerging common law on disgorgement for breach of contract, which has so far eluded explanation. The account also has broader implications for private law theory. First, it suggests that asking whether the plaintiff has a right 'to a thing' (the paradigmatic sort of property right) may obscure the remedial analysis. Instead, the analysis should attend to another, hitherto overlooked aspect of the plaintiff's rights: their logical scope. Second, the account suggests that a purely 'rights-based' understanding of private law remedies cannot adequately explain disgorgement, because it elides the crucial role that the defendant's wrongful action plays in the explanation for the remedy. <http://bit.ly/utlj662a> http://bit.ly/utlj662a REVIEW ARTICLE The politics of comparative constitutional inquiry: At the crossroads of law, political science, and ideology Michel Rosenfeld <http://bit.ly/utlj662r> http://bit.ly/utlj662r University of Toronto Law Journal is available online at Project MUSE - <http://bit.ly/utljpm> http://bit.ly/utljpm UTLJ Online - <http://bit.ly/utljonline> http://bit.ly/utljonline Join the UTLJ email list! Sign up for important news relating to University of Toronto Law Journal. You'll receive emails with peeks inside new issues, Tables of Contents, Calls for Papers, editorial announcements, special offers and journal news. You can unsubscribe at any time and we will never publish, rent or sell your contact details to anyone . Sign up here - <http://bit.ly/utljalerts> http://bit.ly/utljalerts UTP Journals Law & Criminology Newsletter Sign up for the free monthly UTP Journals Law and Criminology newsletter! <http://bit.ly/lawnewsletter> http://bit.ly/lawnewsletter Receive the latest information on newly published research, reviews and opinions as well as Calls for papers, news items and exclusive discounts. You can unsubscribe at any time and we will never publish, rent or sell your contact details to anyone. Full text of the University of Toronto Law Journal is available online at UTLJ Online, Project Muse, JSTOR, HeinOnline, Westlaw, Westlaw-CARSWELL, LexisNexis and Quicklaw. For more information about the University of Toronto Law Journal or for submissions information, contact: University of Toronto Law Journal University of Toronto Press, Journals Division 5201 Dufferin Street, Toronto, ON M3H 5T8, Canada Tel: (416) 667-7810 Fax: (416) 667-7881 Fax Toll Free in North America 1-800-221-9985 Email: <mailto:[log in to unmask]> [log in to unmask] <http://www.utpjournals.com/utlj/utlj.html> www.utpjournals.com/utlj <http://www.facebook.com/utpjournals> www.facebook.com/utpjournals <http://www.twitter.com/utpjournals> www.twitter.com/utpjournals Posted by T Hawkins, UTP Journals