Print

Print
Dear all,

I have for long debated about responding or not responding to these emails. A part of me prevented me from speaking: like Giulio, I am an Italian national and I refuse to have my indignation for what happened be associated to my nationality.  It seems to me that most of the answers to these emails and concerns also came from Italian scholars.  

For long this forum has been used to send CFPs (I did it myself and find it extremely useful to reach colleagues worldwide) and request access to papers that we may not have through our institutions.

As a researcher that has herself been in the Middle East and not always in the safest situations for study/research I feel that this tragic event cannot, and should not, be left 'unattended' and not addressed 'critically' (whatever being critical means). I happily signed the petition promoted by Giulio's supervisors. I thank them for that draft and for taking some steps towards justice for Giulio and all those who have been abducted, tortured or even killed because they are part of some opposition groups in Egypt. But this is not only about Egypt and AlSisi's dictatorship, and this is not only about a white man going to do international research.

What I feel,  is magisterially expressed by Neil Pyper here (http://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2016/feb/06/murder-giulio-regeni-egypt-academic-freedom-students) where he talks about Giulio and the attack to academic freedom.

My question is, what does it mean to be free? What does it mean to be critical at this point? As Pyper puts it, what happened has much broader implications for higher education and research both within and beyond the UK. My question pivots around the role of research and our institutions. Can the researcher be safe and critical? In order to think and act critically, are there mechanisms that we can put in place to safeguard academic freedom without risking lives? How can we protect ourselves? And how should we be protected? 

I wish you all a great Sunday.

Best wishes,

Diana

Dr. Diana Martin

Lecturer in Human Geography, Department of Geography, University of Portsmouth

Email: [log in to unmask] and [log in to unmask]
Twitter: @Diana_Martin_It

On 7 February 2016 at 07:38, Ugo Rossi <[log in to unmask]> wrote:
I agree with Luisa. In addition we should also stress the moral responsibility of the Italian and British governments and the other western governments. Not only the El Sisi government should be the target of our protest but also western governments.

Italy and UK (Giulio was an Italian expatriate in the Uk) have entertained good relationships with the military dictatorship in Egypt because of their economic interests linked to Eni and BP exploiting mineral resources (primarily gas) in Egypt.

when Giulio was still missing a delegation of the Italian government was discussing with the Egyptian authorities about economic investments in Egypt while it was already clear that he had been kidnapped for political reasons.

Giulio was a brilliant and promising scholar, interested in the informal economy and the workers movements, he was a Gramscian. He should be a symbol for all critical geographers across the world.

cheers 
Ugo 


Il sabato 6 febbraio 2016, Luisa Cortesi <[log in to unmask]> ha scritto:
Dear Prof. Alexander and Abdelrahman, Dear Friends of Giulio,

I signed the letter, but I am not sure it is sufficient to express our indignation.

Giulio was one of us. What happened to him can happen to any of us doing research, to any of the students we meet and advice everyday. His horrific death need to shake up the academic community!
Reacting to Giulio's cruel homicide, honors him. And goes beyond him. It reasserts what is the role of the researcher, what it means to do research.

We need a bigger protest.

Tell us who was Giulio. Why he was killed. Put together a short essay about him, a video on youtube and the like. Give us data, help us to realize that he was one of us, that we can be him.

Then, coordinate action: Ask us to flood emails to our Egyptian Embassies, or to the Guardian, or whomsoever it takes. Ask us to send photo of silent students sitting in protest. Each department, at least, of the Humanities and the Soc Sciences, since we have a similar modality of doing research. PolSciences, Anthro, Geography, cultural studies, Middle Eastern, History, etc..

If the death of Giulio speaks of who the Egyptian authorities are right now, how we react to it speaks of who we are, right now, as an academic community, what is our professional collective identity, what is our role in the world we live in.

Please do not read this as condescending, or polemic. I feel we should not miss this opportunity, and you have it right there in your hands. You knew Giulio, and you can lead us to know him, and, in return, to stand up for ourselves.

Regards,
Luisa Cortesi