Print

Print


Hi Fellows,

 

because confusion is becoming a popular search term on the bb, let me admit
to one more:

What is the proper class name for the 65 space groups (you know, those):

 

Are 

(a)    these 65 SGs the chiral SGs and the 22 in the 11 enantiomorphic pairs
the enantiomorphic SGs?

Or 

(b)   the opposite? 

 

In other words, is (a) enantiomorphic a subclass of  chiral or (b) chiral a
subclass of enantiomorphic?

Small molecule crystallography literature seems to tend to (b) whereas in
macro I often find (in terms of number of class members) chiral >
enantiomorphic. Interestingly, did not find an authoritative definition in
ITC-A. 

 

Logical is neither. The 65 are perhaps enantiostatic because they do not
change handedness (as opposed to enantiogen), and the 22 are enantiodyadic
(or so). I am sure Tassos will enlighten us on that one..

 

So, (a) or (b) or ?

 

Happy Easter, BR