Dear CCP4bb,

almost 12h have passed since I posted this question to the board. Since some of us get daily or weekly digests I will hold off with revealing the results. But the replies thus far are really interesting and exciting, and this is without any sarcasm tags. However we have only sampled 1.5% of the CCP4 community thus far.

I will try to have an almost complete reply compiled to all questions raised in the comments box, say in about one week.

Thanks to all those that participated,

Jürgen

......................
Jürgen Bosch
Johns Hopkins University
Bloomberg School of Public Health
Department of Biochemistry & Molecular Biology
Johns Hopkins Malaria Research Institute
615 North Wolfe Street, W8708
Baltimore, MD 21205
Office: +1-410-614-4742
Lab:      +1-410-614-4894
Fax:      +1-410-955-2926
http://lupo.jhsph.edu

On Aug 28, 2013, at 11:32 AM, Bosch, Juergen wrote:

Since we keep discussing resolution cutoffs and the benefits of not to include all data etc.
I thought I would crowd source your opinion on this particular data set.

processed with XDS, here's the XSCALE.LP output:

 SUBSET OF INTENSITY DATA WITH SIGNAL/NOISE >= -3.0 AS FUNCTION OF RESOLUTION
 RESOLUTION     NUMBER OF REFLECTIONS    COMPLETENESS R-FACTOR  R-FACTOR COMPARED I/SIGMA   R-meas  CC(1/2)  Anomal  SigAno   Nano
   LIMIT     OBSERVED  UNIQUE  POSSIBLE     OF DATA   observed  expected                                      Corr

     9.43        5365    1009      1028       98.2%       1.7%      2.1%     5351   68.92     1.8%   100.0*     2    0.698     691
     6.67       10153    1756      1760       99.8%       2.2%      2.4%    10134   58.30     2.4%   100.0*   -12    0.674    1404
     5.44       13114    2217      2223       99.7%       3.4%      3.5%    13097   42.38     3.7%    99.9*   -10    0.716    1845
     4.71       15273    2583      2592       99.7%       3.2%      3.1%    15259   46.24     3.5%    99.9*   -14    0.733    2212
     4.22       17183    2907      2934       99.1%       3.2%      3.2%    17173   45.14     3.6%    99.9*   -16    0.722    2538
     3.85       19010    3183      3217       98.9%       4.4%      4.1%    19000   37.38     4.8%    99.9*   -16    0.717    2794
     3.56       20764    3441      3473       99.1%       5.9%      5.6%    20752   30.36     6.5%    99.9*   -13    0.754    3061
     3.33       22516    3681      3712       99.2%       8.8%      8.5%    22507   22.60     9.7%    99.7*   -11    0.737    3293
     3.14       24735    3963      4001       99.1%      12.4%     13.0%    24725   16.77    13.5%    99.5*    -8    0.696    3565
     2.98       25931    4127      4161       99.2%      17.2%     18.1%    25924   12.82    18.7%    99.2*    -6    0.710    3751
     2.84       26521    4291      4386       97.8%      25.4%     26.9%    26495    9.26    27.6%    98.3*    -4    0.683    3809
     2.72       20357    3495      4592       76.1%      27.6%     29.3%    20277    7.90    30.2%    97.9*     0    0.706    2826
     2.61       15917    2860      4768       60.0%      33.7%     35.0%    15839    6.41    37.0%    96.6*    -2    0.697    2171
     2.52       12949    2394      4944       48.4%      42.5%     45.1%    12877    4.91    46.8%    95.3*     0    0.694    1692
     2.43       10310    1993      5097       39.1%      47.8%     50.7%    10230    4.08    53.0%    94.4*    -2    0.670    1295
     2.36        8180    1693      5309       31.9%      56.4%     60.1%     8079    3.12    63.0%    92.2*    -2    0.671     961
     2.29        6075    1381      5441       25.4%      69.9%     72.5%     5971    2.28    78.9%    87.2*   -10    0.618     643
     2.22        4001    1077      5610       19.2%      82.9%     81.9%     3893    1.78    96.0%    80.7*    -8    0.633     340
     2.16        2491     799      5771       13.8%      78.0%     83.6%     2376    1.47    92.9%    75.9*    -4    0.586     154
     2.11         786     367      5901        6.2%     103.0%    106.4%      666    0.87   129.9%    63.1*    12    0.580      28
    total      281631   49217     80920       60.8%       7.1%      7.2%   280625   21.54     7.8%    99.9*    -7    0.706   39073

And here's the link so you can voice your opinion in a Survey Monkey. Results from this survey will be reported back to the CCP4bb.

http://www.surveymonkey.com/s/YNDKM6G

Thanks for your participation and no there's no iPad or iPod-touch to win, and you also don't have to disclose your email.

The survey has only two questions, one is just a click the other one you provide your opinion on your decision. 

Thanks,

Jürgen

P.S low resolution shell starts at 44 Å - 9.43
P.P.S. the Table1 will be revealed once I report back the outcome of this survey.

......................
Jürgen Bosch
Johns Hopkins University
Bloomberg School of Public Health
Department of Biochemistry & Molecular Biology
Johns Hopkins Malaria Research Institute
615 North Wolfe Street, W8708
Baltimore, MD 21205
Office: +1-410-614-4742
Lab:      +1-410-614-4894
Fax:      +1-410-955-2926
http://lupo.jhsph.edu