Print

Print


Dear Christoph,

I submitted your complaint to the Fieldtrip team. They might need a data
example from you to reproduce the problem.

Best,

Vladimir


On Mon, Mar 18, 2013 at 3:03 PM, Christoph Hofstetter <
[log in to unmask]> wrote:

>  Dear SPM EEG and FieldTrip developers,
>
> I have noticed that from version SPM8 5236 on the conversion of
> BrainVision files gives weird results for me.
> The data set I am using are from intracranial recordings which I converted
> into BrainVision format using cartool. I used the convert (epoch, define
> trials) routine in SPM8 4667 and it worked well. However, when using the
> same approach in SPM8 5236 the results are different and many trials have
> very high peaks (see file attached).
>
> After looking a bit into this issue I found that replacing the following
> SPM8 5236 functions from the SPM8 4667 brought back the same results as
> using pure SPM8 4667:
>
> spm8_4667\external\fieldtrip\fileio\ft_read_data.m
> spm8_4667\external\fieldtrip\fileio\private\read_brainvision_vmrk.m
> spm8_4667\external\fieldtrip\fileio\private\read_brainvision_eeg.m
> spm8_4667\external\fieldtrip\fileio\private\read_brainvision_pos.m
> spm8_4667\external\fieldtrip\fileio\private\read_brainvision_vhdr.m
>
> It seems the problem is rather with FieldTrip than SPM, nevertheless I
> felt like sharing this with you. Please let me know if using the "old"
> fileio FieldTrip functions could be problematic.
> Many thanks in advance for any comments on how to best deal with this.
>
> Best regards,
> Christoph
>
>  ______________________
> Christoph Hofstetter, M.Sc., PhD candidate
> LABNIC, University of Geneva
> http://labnic.unige.ch/nic/htms/hofstetter.html
> +41 (0) 22 37 959 79
>