 |
 |
An interesting discussion. Debs: I think you raise a key issue with your question "Did you talk to any of the young people about their experience?" Rupert: I think this is where your concerns about kids being humiliated or thought of as losers or indeed their de facto inability to give adult consent may be less than perfectly founded. I've observed kids getting involved in all sorts of competitions over the years. They get over losing very quickly in my experience. If anything, winning seems to do more harm. And the harm amounts to a slight swelling of the head. Again fairly temporary. Rhys: "the wrong idea about poetry"??? I appreciate your own immediate second take on this, but come on :) I haven't been to many slams. Some I disliked. Some I thought were exhilarating. I agree with you that it'd be a poor reading that had no performative element, at least at first glance. I remember one reading where the poet sat at a table, a pile of sheets in front of him, and he read the lot without even looking up once. It was mesmerising. It's amazing what will work. And if poetry stops being amazing, that's only temporary too. best Randolph On 28/05/2012 19:05, Deborah Stevenson wrote: > Hey All, > > As the East Midlands Shake the Dust coordinator and someone close to > the heart of this slam program I should probably say something. But I > will keep it brief mainly because I am inexperienced with these kinds > of email discussions and read too slowly to get fully into them. > > You would be surprised at how aware Apples and Snakes and the > directors of the project are about the points you raise. They do not > see Slam as a long term route in to poetry. They see it as a doorway - > once in the child should be quickly ferried out into the diverse and > wonderful world of performance and page poetry. They are aware of > the pitfalls of slam, many of which you have mentioned and I think the > focus is on legacy and awareness. > > Furthermore I think this slam system is better at avoiding > certain pitfalls in comparison to American slam e.g. in the USA > randomly chosen judges hold up score cards to rate the poets whereas > in the UK a panel of experienced poets give each team feedback and a > number of prizes are given at the end with no scores being shown. > > As a 16 year old slam reached me, where conventional poetry wouldn't > off. I think it is more accessible and though I think it is also where > you see the worst poetry and there are a lot of bad things about slam > it can draw young people into writing that might not otherwise find it. > > After that first slam when I was 16 I never attended or ran another > until now so I am approaching it with caution. But I think it is > unfair to lay into what is a project with good intentions for young > people. Did you talk to any of the young people about their experience? > > Debs > > On 28 May 2012 17:43, Rhys Trimble <[log in to unmask] > <mailto:[log in to unmask]>> wrote: > > Generally I agree that slams are awful - and give kids the wrong > idea about poetry ( though what doesn't?). I have been to some > slams in Europe that were more diverse with (extremely) 'serious' > 'literary' poets as some of it's contestants. Slams (perhaps) > arose because of an anti-elitist sentiment that of wanting some > theatricality to be brought to the thing - which isn't altogether > a bad, many poetry readings are a little over-reverential and dry > and a little of the tools slammers use applied to the right > content and with integrity is what is needed from performances > sometimes I think. Those who tread the middle ground and have both > content, and more 'showy' performance - maybe Anthony Joseph, (who > else? LKJ?) someone who can 'do both.' Performance 'skillsets' and > thoughtful poetry not should not be mutually exclusive I don't > think. Wither the Troubadours and Oral Tradition?? > > > No virus found in this message. > Checked by AVG - www.avg.com <http://www.avg.com> > Version: 2012.0.2176 / Virus Database: 2425/5028 - Release Date: 05/28/12 > -- HEX by Randolph Healy U.S. Kindle Store <http://www.amazon.com/HEX-ebook/dp/B007YT27FQ/ref=sr_1_1?s=digital-text&ie=UTF8&qid=1336913755&sr=1-1> U.K. Kindle Store <http://www.amazon.co.uk/HEX-ebook/dp/B007YT27FQ/ref=sr_1_1?s=digital-text&ie=UTF8&qid=1336913370&sr=1-1> Download a free Kindle reading app for pc or mac here <http://www.amazon.com/gp/feature.html/ref=sv_kinh_1?ie=UTF8&docId=1000493771>.