Subject: Cracking job? I'd call it total incompetence


Post by

Roy Clare CBE

Chief Executive Officer

Museums Libraries & Archives Council


Dear Andrew
Mr Clare seems  a little out of touch . Somerset County Council had not done an equalities impact or transport study when it decided it was closing 20 out of its 34 libraries It had not  even had the figures for its settlement, which was better than anticipated with an unexpected 41m capital grant. It announced its public consultation meetings, the majority of which are in towns keeping their libraries, on 16th Dec. How could the most disadvantaged attend a public consultation in towns miles way, relying on Somerset's expensive, patchy rural transport system. It held meeting 9 a.m. to 12.00 when those working could not attend!

Result ,this week a group of parents and children from around Somerset will notify Somerset County Council of their intention to commence legal action into decisions made about the ongoing Library Services Review.  
 
The group will first seek clarification about a recent decision made by Councillor Christine Lawrence and will set out why they consider that Somerset will face both Judicial Review and a costly Public Inquiry into whether the County Council are in breach of their statutory duty to provide a comprehensive and efficient library service, if the Council act based on the decision in question. If a satisfactory reply is not forthcoming from the Council legal action will start.
 
For the group Steve Ross, from Wiveliscombe said "Under the rules for Judicial Review and to avoid unnecessary legal costs we need to clarify the exact nature of the issues we want addressed with Somerset County Council. The information available to the public is unclear. We will explain our position and wait for their reply. While we are waiting we will be asking for a legal undertaking that the current library consultation will be suspended and that no further decisions on the future of the library service will be made by the Cabinet or Council until the legality of the position is clarified".
 
"It would be a shocking waste of taxpayers money for the Council to rely on decisions made and then have to start again because those decisions were found to be unreasonable by a Judge. We hope our action will save Somerset time and money in the long run by providing the Council with an opportunity to stop and reflect on decisions made as well as to consider available alternatives".
 
"The one thing Somerset really can't afford now is wasteful mistakes from it's decision makers".

Mr Clare stated "Where closures are inappropriate or strategies lack imagination or leadership we in MLA are on hand to help. " ..."many more are doing a cracking job for their communities". So where is Mr Clare or is this what he calls  cracking job?

Fiona Kirton
Press Liaison   i
Friends of Glastonbury Library
e: [log in to unmask]
t: 01749 890784
m: 07875596858

“Today’s economic challenge means people need library services more than ever, to help them back to work, to access learning and as a central plank of community cohesion,” said Mr Vaizey, Culture Minster (July 2010)



 


Frances Hendrix
Martin House Farm, Hilltop Lane, Whittle le Woods, Chorley, Lancs PR6 7QR, UK
tel: 01257 274 833.  fax: 01257 266 488
email: [log in to unmask]