From: Mohinder Pal <[log in to unmask]>
To: [log in to unmask]
Sent: Thu, October 21, 2010 7:05:42
AM
Subject: [ccp4bb]
Regarding space group P1, P21
Dear CCP4BB members,
I
have solved a protein-drug complex structure in P21212 space group. In
this structure, the drug molecule is falling on the two-fold symmetry
axis having averaged electron density with 0.5 occupancy. We tried a
lot to crystallize this protein-drug complex in different space group but no
success so far. I have tried to solve the same data in space
group P1 (statistics are fine as I have collected data for 360 degree). The
map looks even better with one conformation for a drug. Interestingly, then
I reprocessed the same data using imosflm in P21 space group which have
penalty 1 compared to 4 for P21212. The structure in P21 is also
refining well (with one conformation of the drug compound without symmetry
axis at the ligand position). The question is , is it a good practice to
solve this structure in P1 and P21 even if the data has higher
symmetry?
Secondly, I have been advised that I have to be careful to
refine structure in P1 as there will be problem regarding
observation/parameter ratio if I add too many water molecules. What will be
the case if the electron density present for water molecules?
I can put restrains to protein structure but I am just
curious to know one restrain equals how many observations.
I look
forward to hear your suggestions.
Kind regards,
Mohinder
Pal