Print

Print


On 8/20/07, Mary Hawking <[log in to unmask]> wrote:
> In message <12576301.1187595413454.JavaMail.root@ps30>,
> "[log in to unmask]" <[log in to unmask]> writes
>
> >I think the list includes
> >
> >1. Islam
> >2. Eastern Orthodox church
> >3. Zoroastrians
> >4. (Some) Orthodox Jews
>
> The question was not whether doctors could have legitimate religious
> objections  to cremation for themselves, but whether such religious
> beliefs would  prevent them from signing cremation certificates for
> others who did not share those beliefs.
> Is there anyone on the list who knows whether, in the case of cremation,
> personally held religious beliefs would include a belief that the very
> act of assisting a non-believer to be cremated is itself a sin? I have
> never come across this being discussed as a matter of conscientious
> objection - but the GMC appear to think it is.
>
> MaryH
>

I believe a Zoroastrian might as their objection is that the element
of fire is too sacred to contaminated by the dead. As mentioned above
I don't think it is a significant currently held belief.

Cheers Geoff