Considering three comparisons with the following F values 1. F(1, 43) = 25.05, p < .01 2. F(1, 43) = 55.05, p < .01 3. F(1, 43) = 26.05, p < .01 I have concluded in my paper that since all three show a significant difference their effect is the same. However, a reviewer has come back with the comment that no. 2 shows 'more sensitivity' as the F value is higher than nos 1 and 2. Does anyone know of any stats which compares F values to show if they are significantly different from another? or is this an odd way of looking at things? thanks