There may be several things going on here. I have been struck since
moving from the Great City to deepest rural Cornwall how much exchanging of
goods without the intervention of money (or the taxman) goes on. People
keep a rough mental record of what is owed: eggs for firewood, leeks for
raspberries -- over long stretches of time. Nowadays, as I say, this is
partly about tax, but chiefly I think convenience and neighbourliness.
You've got the stuff (felled trees, hens, garden), so use it! My neighbour
keeps sheep. He will be giving me the fleeces (which you can hardly give
away at market); after a friend spins it for me (and I pay her), I'll knit
him a sweater, and have loads over....
Not quite on the other hand, but overlapping in many cases, is
cash-poverty. Someone uses your field to keep pigs and can't afford to pay
you rent, but he can leave you a shed full of firewood because he also works as
a tree surgeon.
My grandfather, a general physician in New Jersey 1924-51, kept a record,
sadly now lost, of how his patients paid him. Quite a few never used
money, but what they were able to provide instead in mid-twentieth century East
Rutherford (hardly a rural spot) I don't know!
All of these considerations, with different emphases, would have applied
over the ages, surely.
**********************************************************************
To join the list, send the message: join medieval-religion YOUR NAME
to: