Hi All Just caught up with this discussion re the closure of LIS-CILIP. This was agenda item number 3 at Council. Chris Armstrong's paper on why LIS-CILIP should be retained and Jill Martin's paper on the Communities of Practice were both discussed in detail by councillors. The essence of Chris's paper has already been circulated via this list. I am not going to attempt to summarise the discussion but I felt that all the arguments for keeping the list were well presented. The motion on which we voted was to retain LIS-CILIP alongside the communities of practice. The votes were as follows: For: 11 Against: 23 Abstentions: 7 For the record, I voted to keep LIS-CILIP. I recall that it was also agreed that LIS-CILIP should remain until it can be demonstrated that the Communities of Practice have at least the same number of members and level of participation as LIS-CILIP. Karen -- Karen Blakeman, UKeiG Management Committee mailto:[log in to unmask] t: +44 118 947 2256 f: +44 20 8020 0253 m: +44 7764 936733 88 Star Road, Caversham, Berkshire, RG4 5BE