It wasn't an either/or issue. I was very careful to make that point in my presentation. However, it was convenient to treat it as either/or and to some extent that swung the day. CILIP (which does not moderate or actively monitor and participate in LIS-CILIP) claimed that it did not have staff time to do so in addition to running the communities of practice. Chris Armstrong National Councillor (CILIP) e. [log in to unmask] Information Automation Limited e. [log in to unmask]