Print

Print


In my opinion there is a "full text retrieval bias":

•         Most of HighWire-hosted journals are free after 6-12 months

•         Many health professionals use Google to find the full text
articles. If you paste the title of any article in Google in first 3-4
results you will have the full text-link (more than the MEDLINE link).

•         In MEDLINE, the coloured icons about full text availability, are
soon inaccurate

 

I think that the results could be different for non HighWire-hosted journals
(e.g. for Elsevier or Blackwell)

 

Regards

Nino Cartabellotta

 

-----Messaggio originale-----
Da: Evidence based health (EBH)
[mailto:[log in to unmask]] Per conto di Paul Glasziou
Inviato: giovedě 5 gennaio 2006 15.11
A: [log in to unmask]
Oggetto: Re: Searching for the right search - NEJM piece

 

Badri,

Thanks for the alert - an interesting piece. The most surprising fact 

was the way people now get to Medline articles:

"In June 2005, Google provided the majority (56.4 percent) of the 

referrals from search engines to articles in HighWire-hosted journals 

(see <http://content.nejm.org/cgi/content/full/354/1/4#F1>pie chart). 

PubMed accounted for 8.7 percent, Google Scholar 3.7 percent, and 

Yahoo 3.4 percent. "

Amazing,

Best wishes,

Paul Glasziou

 

At 05/01/2006, you wrote:

>Dear Colleague,

>

>New Year greetings to you all from historic Bury St Edmunds in the 

>east of England.

>

>To day's NEJM carries a piece "Steinbrook R. Searching for the right 

>search - Reaching the medical Literature. New Engl J Med 

>2006;354:4-7". This paper highlights the increasing role of search 

>engines in accessing medical literature.

>

>I though this might be of interest to some of you.

>

>Warm regards & very best wishes,

>

>Badri

>

>Dr.P.Badrinath  MD, BS, M.Phil, MPH, PhD (Cantab), MFPH

>Consultant in Public Health & Affiliated Clinical Lecturer,

>Suffolk West PCT & University of Cambridge, UK

>http://myprofile.cos.com/badrishanthi

>

>Disclaimer: The above views are my own and not that of my employing 

>organisations.

 

Paul Glasziou

Department of Primary Health Care &

Director, Centre for Evidence-Based Practice, Oxford

ph: 44-1865-227055