Dear Brian/All, Doug Douglas who is a teacher researcher at present en route to Brasil (!) with a group of students from Bitterne School in Southampton picked up your forwarded email asking for teachers to contribute - this is his contribution: Q1 collect data. initial debrief of data. sleep on it. revisit, review and adjust accordingly with perspective. Q2a validity - requirement for sufficient evidence ie video, tape, questionnaire, tick sheet, etc Q2b rigour - practice, self-criticism and again the perspective that time gives. sorry it's not much doug Please do have a look at Doug's wonderful web-based snapshot of his research - it's in the What's Going On? Bitterne Teacher Research link from the Home Page http://www.TeacherResearch.net I have already sent this list some teacher researcher webpages from Bitterne - there are others in this section and details of school and our MA programme. You will see that one of the ways we are trying to ensure rigour is in using Critical Thinking Scaffolds - designed by my colleague Dr Steven Coombs - look for the Professional Learning Task Accounts to assist teachers in tracking how critical engagement in literature is informing their practice in classrooms. The Bitterne teachers' webpages are in-process and not due for completion until September but several eg Donna Chipping have already linked in PLTAs. Kind regards Sarah PS The Bitterne section is a draft too and when time allows will be improved - I have lots of video clips and stills to add into our account - coming soon!