Print

Print


> Rui Carvalho wrote:
>
>> But keep in mind that citation counts are the closest we academics have
>> to a
>> democratic system ;)
>

What does one do if one wishes to be critical of a particular methodology
without 'voting' for it?  Omit the citation?

Unless paper citation counts have an equivalent to the rel="nofollow"
attribute for HTML links*, people who judge quality by citation count will
not be getting the whole story, surely?

Tom.

* http://googleblog.blogspot.com/2005/01/preventing-comment-spam.html -
Google's solution to "comment spam" and a method to allow web page owners
to link to things without implicitly endorsing them (arguably a flaw in
Google's PageRank algorithm, but they're in charge of writing the web as
much as reading it nowadays so this is their solution).