Print

Print


Hi Stephen,

On Fri, 18 Feb 2005, Burke, S (Stephen) wrote:

> The broker doesn't really support anything - or else it supports
> everything! The values in the information system are exposed to the
> user, who gets to choose what to put in the Rank and Requirements. The
> default Rank is the EstimatedResponseTime, which in theory should mean
> that jobs go to empty sites first. However, as people have mentioned the
> new information providers have a poor calculation of the ERT which will
> mean that the job distribution will also be poor unless people rank on
> something else.

As someone (maybe you?) has pointed out earlier, if the ERT is to be
useful for ranking sites then it must be calculated in the same way for
each site. That being the case, would it not be more sensible for the
algorithm to be defined by the RB or the UI? Then RB owners or even
individual users could then each use their favourite definition of ERT
based on (supposedly) well defined quantities like number of free CPUs,
rather than arguing about which definition everyone should be "forced" to
use.

Ben

--
Dr Ben Waugh                                     Tel. +44 (0)20 7679 3783
Dept of Physics and Astronomy                    Internal: 33783
University College London
London WC1E 6BT