Jason,
What do you think of this:
"One can and should apply every therapy that is credible in the eyes of the
therapist and the patient, and that has not been proven to be ineffective by
means of sufficient and internally & externally valid research."
In this, "internal" means that the study itself and the analysis have been
designed and performed in correct manners, and "external" means that the results
can be extrapolated to the population the therapist is dealing with (you
know that, but junior students may read this as well).
R.,
Frank
----- Oorspronkelijk bericht -----
Verzonden: dinsdag 13 januari 2004 12:53
Onderwerp: Commentary on EBP
Physio,
I recently had the opportunity to take a
course from George Davies. What struck me was that he spoke in facts
and rarely did he speak in opinions. 90-95% of what
he said was supported with studies. That personal level of
accountability is much more difficult to achieve than giving
opinions. Being able to speak mostly in fact with our patients is
what I believe is the essence of the evidence based movement. I have
been preparing for OCS and I have found this to be the case. Our
profession is striving to push us to a higher level than empirical opinions
now. Don't misunderstand me, empirical thought lays the
groundwork and science either confirms or refutes. It's not an
all or nothing sort of thing. But, there is quite a bit more research
out there than most realize.
From a philosophical standpoint, I'm
wondering if the PT's out there agree with what I'm saying and whether or not
PT's in general embrace evidence-based practice (EBP). There was an
article in the latest PT Magazine, (a publication by the APTA) that said many
PT's are frustrated with the direction that the profession is taking us (i.e.
autonomous, doctorate level, direct access and, most importantly, EBP). I
know we had a rather lengthy discussion on the DPT about a year or so ago and I
don't want to open that back up in detail, I just want to hear the thoughts of
those that participate on this list.
Thanks,
Jason
Jason