Print

Print


Dear Heather,

If I understand your model setup correctly, you haven't explicitly modeled
rest.  Instead you have one EV for each of the force conditions plus one
for all force conditions together.  It is this latter EV that is causing
rank deficiency.  The reason is that this "common force" EV is a linear
combination of the individual force EVs:

common = 1/10*EV1 + 1/20*EV2+1/30*EV3+1/40*EV4*1/50*EV5

But the common force EV doesn't need to be included in the model to extract
the information that you're interested in.  With just the 5 EVs, you can
compute a main effect of force minus rest using the contrast [1 1 1 1
1].  If you mask this inclusively with each of the force conditions
relative to rest, you will guarantee that your effect isn't coming from a
subset of conditions and instead is present in each.  You can do this with
avwmaths.

Then you can look for parametrically changing force effects with whatever
shape you are expecting.  FOr a linear change, you can use [-2 -1 0 1 2]
and for a second-order effect you could use [4 1 0 1 4].  You should note,
however, that since you have an odd number of conditions, each of these
contrasts ignores the middle value (contrast weight of zero) so you'll have
to plot out effect sizes in any area of interest to guarantee that the data
meet your expectations.

Good luck.

Joe

--------------------
Joseph T. Devlin, Ph. D.
FMRIB Centre, Dept. of Clinical Neurology
University of Oxford
John Radcliffe Hospital
Headley Way, Headington
Oxford OX3 9DU
Phone: 01865 222 738
Email:  [log in to unmask]