In a message dated 28/10/04 17:13:56 GMT Daylight Time, [log in to unmask] writes: << The GP has not indicated in his letter that the student has any mobility difficulties or any further complications related to his diabetes, such as a visual impairment. What the GP letter does say is that the student requires a PC because the computing centres are located one mile away from the halls of residence, which suggests to me that it would be convenient for the student to have a PC at home. The GP also stated the need for the student to eat regularly, and this will not be possible if he is unable to work from home. It is a tricky one! >> It's the GP's job to describe the difficulties, not propose solutions which should be based on both the individual's circumstances and their course. IF this IS the only evidence you have then it's not a tricky question at all. There is no justification for recommending a PC on the evidence presented. Mick