The Commonwealth of Design Research vs. J. S. Bach and Glenn Gould - I call to the stand Mr. Glenn Gould. (Mr. Gould seems too absorbed in some kind of remote elaboration. He continuously rubs his arms and wrists.) - Mr Gould! Would you care to come to the bench? - ... - Mr Gould, have you listened to Mr 5 testimony? - I can't help listening. That is my curse. - What do you mean by curse? (let the record show that Mr Gould feels cursed) - It means that I'm constantly seeing the construction of the musical score of every sound that I ear. - Does that mean that someone coughing, sneezing and snoozing has the same possibility of being registered on a musical (!) score as the piano solo that we have been speaking about? - Yes... - For you, there is any difference? - Yes, I'm celebrated for reproducing piano solos and not by reproducing repugnant human noises. - Mr Gould, what is your profession? - I'm a pianist. - Therefore your profession is totally based on a device called piano, in a sense that you exert your profession operating a piano. In the sense that, even without a piano, you should be described as a person who is prepared to follow pianism. Like Marxists don't need to operate marxes to follow Marxism. - Irrelevant - Sustained. Mr X could we get back your previous line of thought? - Sorry, Your Honour, I was merely trying to establish the defendant's pattern of behaviour - Stick to the facts, please. - Mr Gould ... - Yes. - Mr Gould, from your perspective, what is a Marxist? - Objection, Your Honour! - Sustained. - I'll rephrase that: Mr Gould, do you think possible to refer to someone as a dish-washist? - ...? - In a sense that someone earns a living out of manoeuvring a dish- washer? - I guess I could... - From your experience, are the skills required to manoeuvre a piano different from the skills of manoeuvring a dish-washer? - Of course they are different! Dish-washers came with the manuals for their operations. Anyone, by reading those instructions can operate them. Pianists interpret Music. - Mr. Gould, isn't Mr. 5, on his written form, like an instructions manual? - No! Although giving directions, a musical score has nothing to do with an instruction manual for operating a piano. Operating a piano requires persistent daily work to master it and, maybe, there are some cognition powers so specific that only a few can do it in an excel way. - And you would describe that cognition powers as related to the realm of "sensory-motor"? - Yes... May I go outside and put my arms in warm water? - No, Mr. Gould you cant. Can those "special sensory-motor powers" be described as oddities? - In a sense that very few of humans can achieve it, yes. - The piano solo that we have been talking about is something that reveals that kind of oddity? - Yes. - Are you implying that Mr Bach wrote that particular part of Mr. 5 just for oddities? - I don't know... - You mean that you don't know what was Mr Bach design? - I mean that my "special powers" have nothing to do with knowing what Johan Sebastian design fully was since I am only an interpreter, a messenger that, provided with those "special powers", reveals a design to whom is prepared to cognate it. - In that sense you are comparable to the finest of dish-washists... - Yes, if reading, interpreting both the machine and how it operates can be revealing about the nature of dish-washing and about the nature limits of dish-washers. If I could master it I would be that oddity that could bring others near to the design cognition of dish washing apparent on the specific dish-washer operation. - But the final step for design cognition would be performed by others. - Yes, they would have, then, all the data. Meanwhile at the back stage office of the Phineas Cage's Club in Newark: -The guy Gould is cracking up... - Is that a problem for us? - Boss, I can't tell. But that guy gives me the creeps... - Dear Ollie, the Damasio family runs this racket of mapping brains since my grandfather's uncle Egas Moniz started it long time ago... - Tony, we must dispose of this guy! (to be continued) Eduardo