I have no idea where the story comes from but I think we should rule out "unvarnished truth" without delay.  The only real information we have on Scholastica comes from Gregory I's biography of Benedict which makes no mention of any abbey connected to her.  Indeed, I think it significant that he lived in a community and observed fairly strict cloistering and she apparently did not.  She came to visit him and he had to leave his monastery to see her and felt bound to return at night (though he gave in to her entreaties to prolong his visit.)
 
Jo Ann
 
 
 
-----Original Message-----
From: Ms Brenda M. Cook <[log in to unmask]>
To: [log in to unmask] <[log in to unmask]>
Date: Tuesday, January 29, 2002 1:51 PM
Subject: [M-R] St Scolastica and the Trinity

Dear Friendly Experts -
 
A year or more ago I heard this story in a sermon. Now I want to make use of it and wonder if any of you can tell me where it comes from. I esp would like to know if it is a genuine piece of mediaeval myth-making or a later (Romantique ?) fabrication ... [Or even - let's not be narrow-minded! - the unvarnished truth.]
 
I am re-telling what I remember in my own words. (Thus are legends perpetuated .)
 
"Saint Scholastica, sister of Saint Benedict of Nursia, was the abbess of the first nunnery of Benedictine nuns. One cold winter's night she woke in her cell to hear strange music and see a strange light coming through the bars of the shutters. She got up, opened her shutter and looked out into the cloister-garth. In the bright (moon ?) light she saw three beautiful but naked men dancing in the cloister, and one of them was singing like a bird.
 
"St Scholastica closed her shutter, knelt by her bedside and prayed. She prayed firstly, that if those she had seen were mortal men, they would speedily find shelter and warm clothing; but secondly if, as she feared they were demons sent to annoy her, that they would just as speedily go back where they belonged. Then she went back to be with a clear conscience and fell asleep.
 
"In the morning, remembering her disturbed night, she went out into the cloister-garth, and there, in spite of it being mid-winter, all her rose tress were in bloom. Then she realised that what she had seen was a vision of the Holy Trinity."
 
OK, folks. Where does this come from ? I must say I warm to Scolastica's aplomb in the face of a disconcerting experience ....
 
BTW, I have checked Med-Rel Archives before posting this and found nothing, nor does my Dictionary of the Saints give any clues.
 
Brenda M.C.