Print

Print


[log in to unmask] wrote:

>...Alain Erlande-Brandenburg's The Cathedral, a book that would be much, much
more useful if it had footnotes!


AHHRRR-MEN!!!!

Cambridge (or was it Oxenfordbridge?) U.P. deserves some sort of special award
for Vandalism with the publication of that book, completing the decades-old
(now) process of emasculating scholarly works by, first, demanding "end
notes," either at the end of chapters or 
--horribilly dictu-- at the end of the whole text of a book; and, then, simply
eliminating them entirely, substituting in their place some kind 
of "guide for further reading" b.s. (and a "shorter" bibliography).

the idea among the Bean Counters in the Front Office, apparently, is that the
simple appearance of a book with footnotes will scare off all the hoi and the
poloi who would otherwise surely buy the thing from their local Barnes &
Noble's front shelf and turn it into an instant Bestseller (not to mention
lead to a 7 figure contract for the movie rights).

duh.


c






____________________________________________________________________
Get free email and a permanent address at http://www.netaddress.com/?N=1