Dear list:

What is the general opinion on whether one should use the vocational title in a bibliographic citation? 

Leah Rutchick



At 08:10 AM  1/21/01   -0800, you wrote:
I _believe_ Chenu is "Père Chenu, OP." :-)

MG
--- Christopher Crockett <[log in to unmask]> wrote:
> Marjorie Greene <[log in to unmask]> wrote:
>
> >I didn't mean my list to be exhaustive!
>
> sorry.
>
> and i didn't mean that M.-D. Chenu's work was at all
> "discredited" or
> even "old fashioned," nor anything less than very
> substantial
> scholarship, essential preliminary spadework.
>
> just that, in the [ancient] past (c.1930-60, say),
> Art Historians
> (particularly) have made the fellow into a kind of
> unique Patron Saint,
> projecting onto him all sorts of roles (e.g.,
> "inventor" of Gothic
> Architecture) which might just be a bit over-the-top
> as gross simplifications
> of what is increasingly seen as *very* complex
> stylistic developments.
>
> i may (well) be wrong, but Chenu was perhaps one of
> the first historians of
> Theology to look at S's work in detail, from the
> point of view of her(?) own
> particlar discipline; and the Met conference and
> Lindy Grant's book began the
> process of deconstructing his life and work from an
> Historical persepctive,
> the latter (though "officially" an Art Historian)
> utilizing --for the first
> time, i believe-- an extensive
> amount of unpublished (!!) original source material.
>
> freeing him from the more or less exclusive domain
> of the Art Historians --as
> well as re-evaluating his significance within the
> sequence of events within
> that sometimes flakey discipline as that sequence is
> itself re-constructed--
> is a very heartening thing to see, it seems to me.
> an exciting time to be
> alive.
>
> best to all from here,
>
> christopher
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
____________________________________________________________________
> Get free email and a permanent address at
http://www.netaddress.com/?N=1


__________________________________________________
Do You Yahoo!?
Yahoo! Auctions - Buy the things you want at great prices.
http://auctions.yahoo.com/