Dear Shan (and ILT) I'm one of the physicist members of the ILT - and I'm sure your physicist colleagues see Manchester University as a competitor. I'm also an external examiner for their MSc course! Feel free to make whatever use you can of that information. Nevertheless I do see myself as a physicist-who-lectures rather than a lecturer-of-physics, and I suspect that most of my collegues in Manchester, Royal Holloway, and everywhere are pretty much the same. Of course there is a lot of fascinating and useful stuff one can learn from other disciplines, but I think that, at any rate to begin with, people will find it valuable to work with groups within the same subject boundary who share a background and experience and tribal chants. I hope the ILT can move forward in setting up such subject groups (and I'll be happy to offer to help organise/encourage potential ILT physicists.) Roger Barlow %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%