Dear Readers:
Here is the tally of votes with the following notes:
* The typographical error in 12 & 14 has been corrected.
* The following did not receive a majority of positive votes [number of
votes for/against shown in brackets]:
15 & 16 Continues [5/8]& Definition [5/8]
17 & 18 Is ContinuedBy [5/8] & Definition [5/8]
23 & 24 OtherFormat [3/10] & Definition [3/10]
* While receiving a majority of votes, the following do not seem to
represent a consensus:
22 Definition of HasFormat [7/6]
29 & 30 IsBasedOn [7/6] & Definition [7/6]
31 & 32 IsBasisFor [7/6] & Definition [7/6]
Given that # 19, IsFormatOf [10/3], and # 21, HasFormat [9/3] received
majority positive votes, it would seem that we must modify the definition
[7/6] of HasFormat.
IsBasedOn and IsBasisFor seem to need more discussion. Conflict with Source
was noted.
Comments or suggestions?
--Erik
Erik Jul
Relation/Source WG Chair
[log in to unmask]
***************************Ballot Results*********************
N = 13
1. IsPartOf
[12] Yes
[1] No
2. Definition/Usage: The described resource is a physical or logical part
of the referenced resource.
[12] Yes
[1] No
3. HasPart
[12] Yes
[1] No
4. Definition/Usage: The described resource comprises the referenced
resource either physically or logically.
[11] Yes
[2] No
5. IsVersionOf
[13] Yes
[ ] No
6. Definition/Usage: The described resource is a version, edition, or
adaptation of the referenced resource.
[13] Yes
[ ] No
7. HasVersion
[11] Yes
[2] No
8. Definition/Usage: The described resource has a version, edition, or
adaptation, namely, the referenced resource.
[11] Yes
[2] No
9. OtherVersion
[1] Yes
[12] No
10. Definition/Usage: The described resource has a versional relationship
with the referenced resource, but the precedence of the two resources is
unknown.
[1] Yes
[12] No
11. Replaces
[12]Yes
[ ] No
12. Definition/Usage: The described resource supplants, displaces, or
supersedes the referenced resource.
[10] Yes Note: Spelling error corrected.
[3] No Note: Two calls for the addition of "continues" to the definition.
13. IsReplacedBy
[12] Yes
[1] No
14. Definition/Usage: The described resource is supplanted, displaced, or
superceded by the referenced resource.
[10] Yes Note: Spelling error corrected.
[3] No Note: Two calls for the addition of "continues" to the definition.
15. Continues
[5] Yes
[8] No
16. Definition/Usage: The described resource is a logical continuation of
the referenced resource.
[5] Yes
[8] No
17. IsContinuedBy
[5] Yes
[8] No
18. Definition/Usage: The described resource is logically continued by the
referenced resource.
[5] Yes
[8] No
19. IsFormatOf
[10] Yes
[3] No
20. Definition/Usage: The described resource is essentially the same
intellectual content of the pre-existing referenced resource and is
presented in another format.
[10] Yes
[3] No
21. HasFormat
[8] Yes
[4] No
22. Definition/Usage: The described resource pre-existed the referenced
resource, which is essentially the same intellectual content presented in
another format.
[7] Yes
[6] No
23. OtherFormat
[3] Yes
[10] No
24. Definition/Usage: Both the described resource and the referenced
resource contain essentially the same intellectual content in different
formats; the precedence of the referenced resource is unknown.
[3] Yes
[10] No
25. References
[12] Yes
[1] No
26. Definition/Usage: The described resource references, cites, or
otherwise points to the referenced resource.
[12] Yes
[1] No
27. IsReferencedBy
[12] Yes
[1] No
28. Definition/Usage: The described resource is referenced, cited, or
otherwise pointed to by the referenced resource.
[12] Yes
[1] No
29. IsBasedOn
[7] Yes
[6] No
30. Definition/Usage: The described resource is conceptually based on the
referenced resource.
[7] Yes
[6] No
31. IsBasisFor
[7] Yes
[6] No
32. Definition/Usage: The described resource is conceptually the basis for
the referenced resource.
[7] Yes
[6] No
33. Requires
[9] Yes
[4] No
34. Definition/Usage: The described resource requires the referenced
resource, either physically or logically.
[10] Yes
[3] No
35. IsRequiredBy
[10] Yes
[3] No
36. Definition/Usage: The described resource is required by the referenced
resource, either physically or logically.
[ ] Yes
[ ] No
%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
|