I think I'd agree that it was a bit harsh. I really enjoyed the book - not
all the chapters are gems, but there are some really excellent,
illustrative and stimulating contributions. And although they tended to be
geared towards the heavily theoretical, most chapters were both
intelligible and 'grounded' in real life.
Graham Gardner
Institute of Geography & Earth Sciences
University of Wales, Aberystwyth
At 04:50 PM 6/9/99 +0100, you wrote:
>Dear all,
>
>Did anyone see Ron Johnston's review of the Massey, Allen and Sarre edited
>collection called Human Geography Today in the Times Higher last Friday?
>
>Personally, I thought it was a bit harsh, or at least ambivalent, with
>more questions raised then opinions given.
>
>Although I agree very much with Ron Johnston that we shouldn't turn our
>attentions too far away from "firstspace" (what was once called reality),
>I rather liked the book and thought it was quite well grounded in
>empirical work.
>
>I also thought it did a good job of explaining and illustrating the ways
>in which geography - as spatial organization - might matter, rather than
>simply asserting that geography matters.
>
>For an undergraduate looking to get up to date with some of the most
>interesting work in contemporary and sometimes critical human geography I
>thought it would make a really good book. Pretty useful for older hands
>too.
>
>Whad'ya reckon?
>
>cheers,
>alan
>
>PS: non-UK folks with web access can probably find the review at
>www.thesis.co.uk
>
>It was on p.27 if that helps.
>
>******************
>Dr. Alan C. Hudson
>(University Assistant Lecturer and Fellow of Fitzwilliam College)
>
>Department of Geography,
>University of Cambridge,
>CB2 3EN,
>United Kingdom.
>
>Tel: + 44 (0) 1223 333364 (Department - Direct line)
>Tel: + 44 (0) 1223 358354 (Home + Answerphone)
>Fax: + 44 (0) 1223 333392 (Department)
>
>
>
%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
|