On Fri, 18 Dec 1998, Simon Smith wrote:
> 2) I now edit the poetry section of Angel Exhaust
- I welcome this, together with Simon's clearly expressed openness, and
willingness to turn the magazine round from the narrowness which has
threatened it. Following my disgust at Duncan's review of Clive Bush's
book, which remains, but which we've all heard quite enough about on this
list, I'd written to Duncan expressing my unhappiness at being associated
with "his" editorial taste, and requesting that a piece of mine which
he'd accepted for AE some time ago be withdrawn. Duncan's reply was that
it was too late to withdraw the piece, but that he is writing a
supplementary statement. I hope it will in some measure backtrack from the
excesses of that piece. I can't say more than this, for, plainly, it is
now up to Duncan to set those errors to rest.
> 4) Andrew does not have access to the internet, so he is largely unaware of
> this discussion. Last year I recall talk about that rogue Nicholas Johnson,
> and eventually some members pointing out that he had no way to defend
> himself on the list: how is Andrew's position different?
- this seems correct to me. Whilst I'd defend the rights of Bill to defend
himself, as he has done, within the restraints of mailbase netiquette, I
think it has to be acknowledged that nothing further will come from
restating them. As I say, it's up to Duncan now.
Has anyone written
> to AD via the snail to protest about the First Offense article?
- yes, I have (obviously), and I hope others who've read the piece have
too (there can't actually be many of us). His reply, though not effusive
or cordial (I wouldn't have expected this), seemed to suggest that he'd
taken some account of my complaints. I await his subsequent public
statement.
> He certainly has strong, provocative views and expresses them in a
> wayward, often obtuse manner...
- he would do himself and other poets (and members of this list) more
service if his views were also considered and supported.
RC
%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
|