I've never been that keen on the late modernism name game, partly
because the term 'late' adjective installs all kinds of odd qualities of
belatedness, late arrival, late capitalism etc. In one of those
recursive anecdotes that keeps coming round, Frederic Jameson wrote that
'Someone once said that it is easier to imagine the end of the world
than to imagine the end of capitalism.' which puts capitalism on a
strange clock.
The fate of modernism seems to me rather deeply bound up with the fate
of capitalism and for all that these are loose umbrella categories,
comfort food labels rather than sharp concepts, I think modernism
remains continuous as an orientation associated with responses to
modernity, along with reflexive awareness of cycles of innovation,
avant-gardism and aesthetic disorientation in the face of capitalism
across the arts.
I'm a neo-modernist, from an understanding that modernism itself was
largely constituted through struggles to rework and recycle earlier
modernisms, even to the extent of recycling modernist tendencies in
romanticism or in pre-modern materials. Beckett reworks aspects of Joyce
who reworked aspects of Flaubert... and not as anxious influences but as
argued relations between older forms and emergent and concrete realities
that demanded such reworking. But for nearly any concrete argument, it
is the dynamics and qualities underlying the umbrella categories that
matter, eg. epochal categories don't help much if you are trying to work
out the history of collage, found material or compositional
indeterminacy as working parameters. The game of saying that modernists
do one thing, eg. collage and montage, where post-modernists do another,
eg. juxtaposition and indeterminacy, tends to triviality. And 'post'
rarely does much work as an adjective beyond revealing that it needs to
be returned to sender, so that you end up enmeshed in debates about
which version of modernism you are different from, and still essentially
working within modernist terms.
Post-modernism makes more sense in the history of some media and art
forms than others – post-modern architecture came out of a knowingly
kitschy rejection of the international style, the turn against brutalism
and so on, and had a marked preference for superficial neo-classicism.
But you could take your pick whether Bernard Tschumi or Zaha Hadid were
modernist post-structuralists, or whether they were signed up
post-modernists. Post-structuralists with Marxisant tendencies were
often trying to renew modernism under new flags. There was invariably a
bit of Oedipal generation warfare going in. Poetical post-structuralists
and most avowed post-modernists were against the critical and academic
forms of institutionalised modernism, eg. Clement Greenberg, new
criticism, the clerisy model of the lone male modernist as the bard of
tradition preserving culture against the scions of popular culture
etc... but those institutional forms of modernism were also
anti-modernist in the sense that they misrepresented the history of
modernism and reduced it to a few key blokes to be installed as
religious touchstones. For me, the most important and most dynamic
post-modern tendency, one that crosses over with post-structuralism, is
the critique of modernist authoritarianism, the need to think
differentially rather than via Olympian synopses, a.k.a. grand
narratives, or what might be called the myths of modernism. But some
short stories about modernism, such as this one, are attempts to reckon
with the underlying needs embodied in strategic, provisional and
conflictural name games, eg. avant-garde vs modernist, because sometimes
if you throw out an umbrella term you end up ignoring the needs
embodied, while installing the critical problem in some other term: eg.
ecopoetics as neo-modernist ecological poetics in disguise?
I wrote an essay about all of this, entitled 'Neo-modernism and
avant-garde orientations' in the Concise Companion to Postwar British
and Irish Poetry, eds Alderman and Blanton,
<http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1002/9781444310306.ch8/summary>.
Drew
|