1 These are not the numbers I would normally use, but strategy A seems rather overfitted/ under restrained. So without other information I would go for strategy 2.
2 These are not numbers that I would normally use, but given no other information other than this, I would choose strategy A as strategy B seems rather over-restrained.
3 Why is the choice between A and B? Why not C? A & B seem to be opposite extremes, what happens if you aim for a RMSbonds value in the middle, say 0.01?
4 Modify strategy B with little easy on weights.
Is this an example of lively scientific debate to achieve scientific consensus? I do appreciate the artful language shifts in comments 1 vs 2. I can only hope both of the reviewers are in the same camp!
JPK
|