**Please note that if you press the Reply button to respond to this mailing, it will be distributed to everyone on the Childlore List. If you want to make a personal reply, you will need to modify the Reply-To line of your message.**
I have been thinking how I came to the conclusion that tomatoes equals
children in the joke.
1. Children knows that a tomato can not move by itself. It does not posses
feet.
2. Children knows that to cross a road you have to have feet or wheels or
being able to fly. Tomatoes cannot walk, roll or fly.
3. When a tomato are crushed it's impact on the road will be similar to
that of blood, huiman or what is the result of a crushed animal, like a cat
or a hedgehogs (the two most common items children are familiar with)
4. A parent are likely to sumond his/her child when something happens.
5. A crushed baby looking like a crushed tomato must appear funny
(unexpected) and is in line with many other jokes on the wild side of life.
I do not suppose that children are familiar with Nestons laws on objects,
but they sure can imagine pictures in their own heads...
I observed once some girls in 4th grade skipping ropes. They used one short
rope, one girl swinging it over her head while the others jumped in or out
as they do in "Teddybear, Teddybear". The funny thing was that they had
made a song I never had heard before: Helicopter, Helicopter, jump. jump
jump, helicopter helcopter come home now, helicopter helicopter hop out
now.... (or something like it, I have the text somewhere but cannot get it
right now...)
The point is: This was a primary school on an island in Stavanger where
most of the men-folk worked offshore on the oil instalations in the
Northsea. They have to travel in helicopters no matter how rough the
weather. It happened that the helicopters crashed and that people lost
their lifes. I figure the kids were examining their fear for what could
happen to their fathers on duty on the high seas...
The same thing I experienced with an exibition of childrens 3d
constructions in the Cultural Center in Stavanger. The motto for the event
was "My father works in oil(bussiness)" Most of the items was constructions
of oil-rigs and drawings. The interesting things were that the
constructions was very detailed, but tecknical details was missing. But
there were an overwhelming amount of lifeboats, helicopters, lifefloats and
supplyships, everything that could bring their parents safe ashore. And the
drawings gave the same impact, and in addition there were many drawings of
Jesus Christ (as the Saviour) walking on the waves reaching out for the
people on the plat-form... You don't have to be a genius to see what the
kids were telling...
I would be very honoured if you could see that you lend a bit of your
consideration to these thoughts as it mean something to me that we can be
assured that we understand what kids are telling us when they keep their
thoughts to themselves....
All the best,
Thor G.
Original email:
-----------------
From: Andy ARLEO [log in to unmask]
Date: Sun, 26 May 2013 13:57:13 +0200
To: [log in to unmask]
Subject: Re: interpreting smashed tomatoes
**Please note that if you press the Reply button to respond to this
mailing, it will be distributed to everyone on the Childlore List. If you
want to make a personal reply, you will need to modify the Reply-To line of
your message.**
Thanks, Thor. That smashed tomatoes may be a metaphor for babies/
toddlers for some chldren is an interesting proposal, but I often feel
that such interpretations lack evidence to back them up. If we were to
find texts within and across cultures that support this idea, I would
be more convinced. Better yet, we could ask kids themselves for their
own interpretations. But even if some kids did explicitly say that
they identify tomatoes and toddlers, that would not mean that all kids
do. So I see it as a potential metaphor, and now that you've planted
it in my brain, it will influence my own future interpretations of
"smashed tomatoes." Perhaps a psychoanalytical approach would suggest
that it was already there in my unconscious mind waiting for someone
like you to bring it to awareness (now how could that be proved or
disproved?).
The fact that kids like to hear a joke about tomatoes crossing a
motorway does not necessarily imply that this "means something else".
Simply imagining tomatoes as people (metaphorical thinking) is
incongruous and amusing in itself for kids young and old.
Cheers, have a pleasant Sunday,
andy
Le 25 mai 13 ŕ 10:41, [log in to unmask] a écrit :
> **Please note that if you press the Reply button to respond to this
> mailing, it will be distributed to everyone on the Childlore List.
> If you want to make a personal reply, you will need to modify the
> Reply-To line of your message.**
>
> Dear all
>
> Jane Stemp Wickenden ask: What is it with english schoolchildren and
> smashed tomatoes??
>
> Smashed tomatoes translates to babies/toddlers. Children cannot
> eksperience
> with grown ups beating up children but they can see smashed tomatoes
> and
> the similarities to blood. Come on ketchup, is a common joke in
> kindergartens, perhaps in a global context...
>
> When 99% of children in a kindergarten demands to tell you this joke
> about
> the two tomatoes crossing a highly trafficked motorway, it must mean
> something else to them then...
>
> All the best,
> Thor G.
>
>
> Original email:
> -----------------
> From: Andy ARLEO [log in to unmask]
> Date: Fri, 24 May 2013 12:44:08 +0200
> To: [log in to unmask]
> Subject: Re: BBC radio 3 program on Frère Jacques - parody
> asrequested
>
>
> **Please note that if you press the Reply button to respond to this
> mailing, it will be distributed to everyone on the Childlore List.
> If you
> want to make a personal reply, you will need to modify the Reply-To
> line of
> your message.**
>
> great, thanks for these versions!
>
>
>
>
>
>> Message du 23/05/13 19:52
>> De : "Jane Stemp Wickenden"
>> A : [log in to unmask]
>> Copie Ă :
>> Objet : Re: BBC radio 3 program on Frère Jacques - parody as
>> requested
>>
>> **Please note that if you press the Reply button to respond to this
> mailing, it will be distributed to everyone on the Childlore List.
> If you
> want to make a personal reply, you will need to modify the Reply-To
> line of
> your message.**
>>
>> Andy,
>>
>> Not sure you would want to *hear* me singing it! I suppose it is
>> not so
> much
>> a parody as a song to the same tune, and it is embarrassingly puerile
> (well
>> I was only 9). The year must have been about 1970, because I recall
>> both
> my
>> brothers joining in, and they're 2 years and 5 years younger than
>> me. We
>> lived in the south of Surrey, about 20 miles from London.
>>
>> Ahem...
>>
>> Squashed tomatoes, squashed tomatoes
>> Irish stew, Irish stew
>> Soggy semolina, soggy semolina
>> I feel sick, I feel sick.
>>
>> (what is it about the British schoolchild and squashed tomatoes?)
>>
>> I've just asked my husband, and he remembers a version whose first
>> two
> lines
>> were
>>
>> Bread and butter, bread and butter
>> Spotted dick, spotted dick
>>
>> - this seems likely to be the original to judge by the matching
>> rhymes? It
>> was about 1964, and he was living in north-west London.
>>
>> For the purposes of clarification I should perhaps add that
>> "spotted dick"
>> is the name for a rolled-up, boiled, suet pudding filled - often
>> sparsely
> -
>> with currants.
>>
>>
>> Jane
>>
>>
>> -----Original Message-----
>> From: The Children's Folklore Mailing List
> [mailto:[log in to unmask]]
>> On Behalf Of Andy ARLEO
>> Sent: 23 May 2013 15:11
>> To: [log in to unmask]
>> Subject: Re: BBC radio 3 program on Frère Jacques
>>
>> **Please note that if you press the Reply button to respond to this
> mailing,
>> it will be distributed to everyone on the Childlore List. If you
>> want to
>> make a personal reply, you will need to modify the Reply-To line of
>> your
>> message.**
>>
>> Thanks, Jane. I would love to hear, or have the words, to your
>> parody!
>>
>> Â
>>
>> I just got a message from the producer (below), in case you want to
>> listen
>> to the program in the next week.
>>
>> Â
>>
>> cheers,
>>
>> Â
>>
>> andy
>>
>> Â
>>
>> Dear Andy, Adam and Richard,
>>
>>
>> I’m very pleased to let you know that my feature on “Frere
>> Jacques”,
> titled
>> “Are You Sleeping, Brother John” will be broadcast TONIGHT
>> (Thursday
> 23rd
>> May) at around 8.15pm UK time on BBC Radio 3, in the interval of
>> live in
>> concert.
>>
>> Â
>>
>> You can listen to it live, anywhere in the world at the BBC Radio 3
> homepage
>> www.bbc.co.uk/radio3 - and for 7 days after transmission (UK only) at
>> http://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/b01sj122
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>
>>> Message du 21/05/13 22:45
>>> De : "Jane Stemp Wickenden"
>>> A : [log in to unmask]
>>> Copie Ă :
>>> Objet : Re: BBC radio 3 program on Frère Jacques
>>>
>>> **Please note that if you press the Reply button to respond to this
>> mailing, it will be distributed to everyone on the Childlore List.
>> If you
>> want to make a personal reply, you will need to modify the Reply-To
>> line
> of
>> your message.**
>>>
>>> Well done Andy!
>>>
>>> My brothers and I drove my mother mad by singing a parody of this
>>> in the
>>> 1970s...
>>>
>>> Here is the exact link to the programme:
>>> http://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/b01sj122
>>>
>>> Jane
>>>
>>>
>>>
>>>
>>> Jane Stemp
>>>
>>> Waterbound (Hodder, 1995) / Secret Songs (Hodder, 1997)
>>> contributor: The Sixpenny Debt - The Lost College - The Bodleian
> Murders -
>>> The Midnight Press / & other Oxford stories (2006, 2008, 2010, 2012
>>> [forthcoming])
>>>
>>>
>>> -----Original Message-----
>>> From: The Children's Folklore Mailing List
>> [mailto:[log in to unmask]]
>>> On Behalf Of Andy ARLEO
>>> Sent: 21 May 2013 15:01
>>> To: [log in to unmask]
>>> Subject: BBC radio 3 program on Frère Jacques
>>>
>>> **Please note that if you press the Reply button to respond to this
>> mailing,
>>> it will be distributed to everyone on the Childlore List. If you
>>> want to
>>> make a personal reply, you will need to modify the Reply-To line
>>> of your
>>> message.**
>>>
>>> Dear All,
>>>
>>> Â
>>>
>>> BBC Radio 3 will be airing a program on Frère Jacques on Thur May
>>> 23
>> around
>>> 8:15pm UK time. Thanks to Julia Bishop, I was contacted and
>>> interviewed
> by
>>> the producer. You can listen to it live at:
>>>
>>> Â
>>>
>>> Â www.bbc.co.uk/radio3Â
>>>
>>>
>>> Best regards,
>>>
>>>
>>> Andy
>>>
>>
>
>
> --------------------------------------------------------------------
> mail2web LIVE – Free email based on Microsoft® Exchange technology -
> http://link.mail2web.com/LIVE
--------------------------------------------------------------------
mail2web.com – What can On Demand Business Solutions do for you?
http://link.mail2web.com/Business/SharePoint
|