Thanks, Salvo. Actually, rather than suffering the brutal editing of the
Guardian subs, can I recommend to everyone the original piece in the
British Journalism Review at http://www.bjr.org.uk/ ("On the Road to
Self-Destruction") which has full tables as well as the non-truncated
and slightly more sophisticated argument.
There's also a fascinating piece by Damien McCrystal for those of us who
worry about the migration (stampede?) of professional journalists into
PR. A view from the coal-face of why the process is accelerating.
All best
Steve
Prof Steven Barnett
Professor of Communications
School of Media, Art and Design
University of Westminster
Watford Road, Harrow
Middlesex HA1 3TP
Direct Line: +44 (0)20 7911 5981
email: [log in to unmask]
-----Original Message-----
From: Media, Communications & Cultural Studies Association (MeCCSA) -
Policy Network [mailto:[log in to unmask]] On Behalf Of
Salvatore Scifo
Sent: 27 May 2008 09:56
To: [log in to unmask]
Subject: Journalism: 'A loss of faith', S.Barnett, The Guardian, 26 May
Dear All,
attached below an article by Steven Barnett, published yesterday on The
Guardian website, that might interest members of this list.
Best Wishes,
Salvo
--------------------------------------------------------------------
Source:
http://www.guardian.co.uk/media/2008/may/26/pressandpublishing.televisio
n
A loss of faith
* Steven Barnett
* guardian.co.uk,
* Monday May 26 2008
Public faith in journalism has never been strong, with the average
journalist being placed somewhere between secondhand car dealers and
estate
agents in the league table of trust.
(Table link: http://media.guardian.co.uk/page/0,,2282003,00.html )
In fact, public attitudes have always been more complex than the image
of a
shady doorstepper suggests.
In general, we are better disposed to broadcast journalism than to
print,
and to journalists on the quality papers than the mid-market or red
tops.
Certain kinds of journalism within certain kinds of institutions have,
contrary to conventional wisdom, inspired a great deal of trust.
That may be changing. Our YouGov survey repeated the question asked five
years ago about 23 different occupations: "How much do you trust the
following to tell the truth?".
The groups included seven kinds of journalist from BBC TV to red-top
tabloid, and all except one have performed worse than every other group.
The worst performers are ITV and Channel 4: those saying they trust ITV
journalists have declined 31% in five years (from 82% to 51%), while
trust
figures for C4 journalists are down 29% (from 80% to 51%). The BBC's
trust
figures are down 20%, from 81% to 61%.
Print journalism's performance is on a par with the BBC's. Trust in
broadsheet journalists is down 22%, in local journalism down 20% and in
mid-market journalism down 18%.
The only group to emerge unscathed were the red-top journalists, whose
reputation was so low it could hardly sink further. Just 15% trust
red-top
reporters to tell the truth - slightly better than estate agents.
Other occupations such as police, teachers and NHS managers have also
suffered, but the decline in trust is significantly more severe in
journalism.
Why this apparent collapse in public confidence?
There's the drip-drip effect of the "fakery" revelations over the past
18
months. The link from Ant and Dec to BBC newsrooms may be tenuous, but
it's
logical that damage to institutional credibility will impact especially
on
news output.
There's the dog-eat-dog effect of competitive media organisations
deriving
pleasure from their rivals' pratfalls.
Newspapers, in particular, like to give broadcasters a good kicking,
especially when celebrities are involved.
Does it matter? One argument holds that trust in the media is overrated,
and
that the more the public distrusts journalism the healthier it will be.
This is hardly a recipe for a well-informed democracy, and do we really
want
to tell the many bright students coming into journalism that their
chosen
occupation is too degraded to be worth the candle?
Good journalism makes a difference to the kind of society we live in,
and to
distrust it is eventually to destroy it.
* Steven Barnett is professor of communications at University of
Westminster.
* A longer version of this article appears in the British Journalism
Review,
vol 19 no 2, available from SAGE Publications, 1 Oliver's Yard, 55 City
Road, London EC1Y 1SP, subscriptions hotline + 44 (0) 20 7324 8701,
email
[log in to unmask]
------------------------------------------------------------------------
--
--
Salvatore Scifo,
Lecturer in Community Media
Media Information & Communication
Department of Applied Social Sciences
London Metropolitan University
Ladbroke House, Room LH 326
62-66 Highbury Grove
London N5 2AD
W: www.communitymedia.eu
-------------------------------------------------
MeCCSA Policy mailing list
W: http://www.jiscmail.ac.uk/lists/meccsa-policy.html
Please visit this page to browse list's archives, or to join or leave
the list.
--
The University of Westminster is a charity and a company limited by
guarantee. Registration number: 977818 England. Registered Office:
309 Regent Street, London W1B 2UW, UK.
-------------------------------------------------
MeCCSA Policy mailing list
W: http://www.jiscmail.ac.uk/lists/meccsa-policy.html
Please visit this page to browse list's archives, or to join or leave the list.
|