> Jasp:
> > Hang on a minute (don't want to get bogged down In Superman, but...):
> >
> > Clark Kent and Superman are the same person. Clark Kent can run faster
> > than a speeding train, and Superman fancies Lois Lane. It is just
> > that, for reasons of his own, Clark Kent puts his underpants on over
> > his trousers whenever he is fighting crime.
> >
> > Superman is just another name for the same person. It's the style he
> > adopts for his superhero activities, just as I style myself 'Jasp' on
> > this list.
>
> As I said in my original message, if asked to draw (or describe) Clark
> Kent and to draw Superman, people will draw them differently. So the
> concepts are distinct, even though they are also 'the same person'
No the concepts are not distinct. They just look different. There's
this fellow from the planet Krypton (or wherever it is) and sometimes
he wears glasses and looks like a bit of a nerd, and sometimes he
wears his underpants over his trousers and leaps tall buildings at a
single bound. The latter dress and behaviour are usually associated
with the activity of crime-fighting.
It looks to me just like the case of {I}/{me}: there's this word ME,
which is pronounced sometimes /mi:/ and sometimes /ai/. The latter
pronunciation is associated with the syntactic role subject (at least
in my English, I know other people's grammars are more complicated).
Jasp
|