My opinion Andrew M. Greeley: IRA's struggle justified
http://www.dailystar.com/dailystar/opinion/90157.php
25 August 2005

The editorial boards of The Wall Street Journal and The New York Times - the 
"official" thought molders of the nation - rarely agree on anything. 
Recently, however, they managed to agree on one subject. Both condemned the 
Irish Republican Army on the grounds that there was no justice in its 
claims.

The violence of the Stern Gang in Israel, the African National Congress in 
South Africa, the FLN in Algeria is apparently OK (at least to The Times), 
but the IRA does not have a legitimate cause. Such ignorance of Ireland's 
history is intolerable. We should expect better reporting from both of them.

England had no right to occupy Ireland and exploit and persecute the Irish 
people for half a millennium. When it was finally forced by the original IRA 
to grant quasi-independence to Ireland in the early 1920s, it had no right 
to carve out a gerrymandered rump state in the North of Ireland for the 
descendants of its colonists.

Moreover it had no right to shape that last surviving colony in Europe (six 
of the nine counties of historic Ulster) so that its Protestant inhabitants 
could oppress the artificially created Catholic minority. Nor did England 
have the right to tolerate for a half-century political, social, educational 
and religious persecution of Catholics.

Small wonder that this rule by a "Protestant Parliament for a Protestant 
nation" created such social injustice that there was a violent revolution.

While the IRA claims a vision of a united Ireland - a vision that is 
certainly historically justified - it was in fact fighting the unjust 
oppression of Catholics in this lingering relic of English imperialistic 
colonialism.

I deplore violence everywhere, but the long history of Ireland's quest for 
freedom from English domination demonstrates that it has had to fight for 
justice every inch of the way.

Hardly an article about British-occupied Ireland appears in American papers 
does not describe the IRA in any other terms than its claim for Irish unity. 
Hardly a word appears about the blatant injustice of the colonial regime.

The IRA finally forced the English government to the negotiating table. 
Kicking and screaming, the Protestant leadership joined the negotiations.

The result was the historic Good Friday agreement that imposed a complex 
form of power sharing on the Protestants. Since then, the Protestant 
leadership, having failed to persuade its constituents of the absolute 
necessity of power sharing, has torpedoed every attempt to implement the 
agreement.

The IRA promised in the Good Friday agreement to disarm when the other 
conditions of power sharing had been established.

The Protestant leadership managed to persuade the world that the IRA was the 
barrier to peace when in fact they - or their followers - were and are the 
real obstacle.

No oppressive ruling class ever gives up power easily. Protestants in the 
North are still not ready to give up their illusion of a "Protestant" 
nation. Protestants are still throwing gasoline bombs into the homes of 
Catholics in South Armagh - something The Journal and The Times will not 
report.

The IRA ceased fire seven years ago in the hope justice could be achieved by 
peaceful negotiations. It has finally gone the last mile by voting to give 
up all arms and disband. Will that satisfy the country's hard-line 
Protestants? Based on past performance there is no reason to think that it 
will.

The Rev. Andrew M. Greeley, a Catholic priest, teaches at the University of 
Chicago and the University of Arizona. Contact him at [log in to unmask] 


	
	
		
___________________________________________________________ 
Yahoo! Messenger - NEW crystal clear PC to PC calling worldwide with voicemail http://uk.messenger.yahoo.com